Unfinished business in Delaware River’s polluted urban stretch

Push for stricter oxygen standards part of larger fight to save watershed

This article is part of a series: “Water’s Edge: Trials and tributaries of the Delaware River Watershed.” Register here for a free, virtual roundtable on March 1.

The Delaware River’s urban estuary between Palmyra and Wilmington, Delaware was first a poster child for pollution and then an exemplar of large-scale environmental cleanup. Now it is the focus of discussions over how to finish the decades-long job of reviving the river.

The 38-mile stretch in one of the river’s most densely populated areas is much cleaner than the “open sewer” that it had become by the mid-20th century, in the words of the Delaware River Basin Commission, the interstate regulator that has led the river’s recovery.

Fish now migrate beneath the Ben Franklin Bridge connecting Camden to Philadelphia where the absence of oxygen at certain times of year previously created a “dead zone” with fish unable to survive. Bald eagles hunt nearby, and people sail, ride Jet-Skis, and even swim in the waters.

But environmentalists and state and federal officials agree there’s more work to be done to remove the oxygen-depleting ammonia that flows out of the wastewater treatment plants along that section of the river.

≋  Aerial view of Delaware River as it flows around Petty’s Island in the heart of the urban estuary. Credit: dsearls via Creative Commons; CC BY 2.0

Advocates for a higher standard of cleanup have argued for years that the commission should increase its requirement for the concentration of oxygen in the urban river — a standard called dissolved oxygen — and upgrade its “designated use” of the estuary for fish from the current “maintenance” to “propagation.”

Wastewater treatment

Those changes, which could be achieved by requiring the wastewater treatment plants to reduce ammonia discharges, would improve conditions for fish, especially the critically endangered Atlantic sturgeon, to breed and migrate, while improving water quality for drinking and recreation, advocates say.

An icon of the sturgeon of the NJ Delaware river
Atlantic sturgeon

Scientific name: Acipenser oxyrinchus

NJ location: Delaware River

Problem: The river’s once-teeming population has been decimated by pollution, overfishing, lack of oxygen and strikes from large ships.

Learn More

The Delaware River runs the length of New Jersey’s western boundary, and through its branches and tributaries feeds water to over 13 million people in the Delaware River Watershed, giving life to plants, animals and insects in an area that covers nearly 13,000 acres in four states.

In this series “Waters Edge: Trials and Tributaries of the Delaware River Watershed,” NJ Spotlight News examines the state of the watershed, including the challenges from New Jersey’s legacy of industrialization, the impacts of commercial and residential development as well as the threats posed by a changing climate. It also explores how some of these challenges have been met and the progress made — progress that involves fights like the one over the technical standard for dissolved oxygen in the river, a threshold that can mean literal life or death for the fish that live in the Delaware.

In 2017, the Delaware River Basin Commission began an investigation into whether the dissolved-oxygen standard and the estuary’s designated use could be raised by tightening requirements on the water treatment plants. But environmental groups continued to accuse the commission of being too slow to raise the water quality standard. In April, five activist groups filed a petition with the Environmental Protection Agency, asking it to set its own rules on upgrading the estuary’s water quality, using its authority under the federal Clean Water Act.

The petition accused the commission of “failing to discharge its duty to protect the health of the Delaware River Estuary at the expense of valuable aquatic life.”

In September, the commission ended its study with a plan to set stricter standards for nine of the treatment plants — three of which are in New Jersey — that discharge into the urban section of the river.

But that report, the “Analysis of Attainability,” was upstaged on Dec. 1, when the EPA unexpectedly granted the environmentalists’ petition. It said the existing standards on dissolved oxygen and designated use — both of which have been in place for 55 years — do not meet the requirements of the Clean Water Act, and that both measures “must be revised” to protect the propagation of resident and migratory fish.

The federal agency said it expected to write a rule within 12 months, which would be in advance of the commission’s prediction that it would finish its own rule-making process by March 2025. But the federal determination said nothing about the extra time that adoption and promulgation of a rule would take.

Despite environmentalists’ claims that EPA had superseded the Delaware River Basin Commission, both agencies played down suggestions that they were working separately to raise water quality standards in the urban river.

The EPA welcomed the work that the commission has put into the issue so far. It said its determination does not stop the commission proceeding with its own rule-making, and that it would welcome the opportunity to discuss whether the regulator’s March 2025 deadline could be accelerated.

A map showing the region of the Delaware River bordering urban areas

The Delaware River Basin Commission’s executive director, Steve Tambini, said activists had “misrepresented” the EPA’s report and that he had “no significant objection” to it. Tambini said he planned to continue to work with the federal agency and other stakeholders on raising water quality in the estuary. The agency represents the water interests of the four basin states — New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania and Delaware — plus the federal government.

The commission’s September report concluded that it is technically feasible to reduce the ammonia content coming from the nine plants to the point where dissolved oxygen would significantly increase, and the designated use of that section of the river would be upgraded to be consistent with the propagation of fish.

The report determined that the plants contribute 96% of the ammonia-nitrogen load discharged into the estuary. It recommended that the commission update its rules to allow for the new standard of use, and formally adopt a new oxygen standard that would create the right conditions for fish propagation.

“The addition of technically feasible advanced treatment by nine major wastewater treatment plants discharging to the estuary will significantly improve the level of dissolved oxygen that can be achieved, and that water quality supporting the aquatic life use of ‘fish propagation’ is attainable throughout the estuary,” said the 96-page draft report.

It said the cost of installing technology in the water treatment plants that discharge into the urban section of the river will be “significant” but that would not be a financial burden for households served by the plants. 

The report does not specify a dissolved oxygen level that would be required under new rules; rather, it models potential improvements in oxygen that would be achieved with different levels of investment in treatment plant technology.

At present, the plants’ output is designed to maintain dissolved oxygen in the water at a concentration of 3.5 milligrams per liter, a level that environmentalists say restricts the breeding of fish, especially the biologically unique local population of Atlantic sturgeon, of which 250 spawning adults are believed to survive. The Delaware River Basin Commission’s September report concluded that advanced wastewater treatment could increase the oxygen level by about 2.3 milligrams per liter during the summer when that measure drops to its lowest levels of the year.

The standard was set by the commission in 1967 as a compromise between environmentalists and industrial interests that were faced with the installation of pollution-control equipment to curb the output of carbon-based oxygen depletion in the water — a process called “carbonaceous biochemical oxygen demand.”

What regulators have not addressed

While the reduction of that carbon-based oxygen depletion has been crucial to the river’s recovery so far, regulators have not addressed the other main source of oxygen depletion: that from nitrogen in ammonia produced in human waste, creating a condition in the water called “nitrogenous biochemical oxygen demand.”

Different aquatic species require different levels of dissolved oxygen to thrive but any water with a dissolved oxygen level under 3 milligrams per liter is a cause for concern, according to the EPA.

The annualized cost of reducing ammonia to produce a big increase in dissolved oxygen would be $150 million a year for all nine water treatment plants, including construction, operation and maintenance, according to the new study.

That’s in line with an annual $157 million for the same standard of cleanup, as calculated by Kleinfelder, a consultant, in a report for the Delaware River Basin Commission in January 2021.  

That new cost estimate would produce an increase of between 2 and 2.5 milligrams per liter, leading to a dissolved oxygen level of 5.5-6 milligrams per liter — significantly higher than the current level. The analysis also looked at whether more gains in dissolved oxygen could be achieved by spending more on treatment technology, and concluded that the benefits of spending more than $150 million would be minimal.

≋  Camden County Municipal Utility Authority’s water treatment plant on the banks of the Delaware River. Credit: Michael Innella, North Jersey Drone Shots LLC

The cost of retrofitting treatment plants would mean higher water bills for the approximately 3.5 million people served by the nine plants, but split between all those users, it would be affordable, argued Dr. Jerry Kauffman, director of the University of Delaware’s Water Resources Center, and a longtime advocate for an upgrade in the oxygen standard.

The extra per-person cost for the plants’ customers works out at about $45 a year, Kauffman said. “That’s about $3.50 a month, or the price of a cheap wine at Trader Joe’s. That’s affordable,” he said. The per-customer cost would decline further if it was split between all the approximately 6 million people who live in the Delaware River Watershed below Trenton, he said.

A sojourn like no other

For almost three decades, the annual Delaware River Sojourn has brought people out onto the great waterway. Last spring, reporter Jon Hurdle joined the journey downriver on a 13-mile stretch from Bushkill, Pennsylvania to Worthington State Forest in New Jersey. Read what he found.

Learn More

Asked whether the measures would make the urban river “fishable and swimmable” — a goal that was set for all waterways by the federal Clean Water Act in 1972 — Kauffman predicted that the proposed upgrade would remove any doubt that the river was fishable.

But making the urban river truly swimmable again would require more improvements to the area’s combined sewer overflows — antiquated drains that dump stormwater and raw sewage into the river during heavy rains — than are proposed in the new report, he said.

Kate Schmidt, a spokeswoman for the Delaware River Basin Commission, said the report is just a draft which is now subject to review by stakeholders including other agencies, treatment plant operators, members of its Water Quality Advisory Committee, and the governors of New Jersey, New York, Pennsylvania and Delaware plus the federal government, who together make up the commission.

“The release of the draft … is the culmination of five years of an intensive and technical effort that involved data collection, the development of water quality models, the completion of scientific analyses, and collaboration with multiple stakeholders; however, this is just one step in the process,” she said.

This article is part of a special series by NJ Spotlight News and funded by the William Penn Foundation. The project homepage is your roadmap to the series. Send us your stories and photos about the Delaware River region.

More in this series