Credit: (Taylor Jung/NJ Spotlight News)New Jersey has one of the most segregated K-12 public school systems in the country, an imbalance that is linked to racial and socioeconomic inequality.
With a new governor with the power to change that set to take office and a long-standing school segregation lawsuit reaching state appellate court, change could be on the horizon.
Desegregation court cases often take a long time and are demanding on judges since the issues are so complex, said Gary Orfield, co-director of The Civil Rights Project at UCLA. And whoever is governor has influence since they can choose to support or stall the case.
A group of parents and advocates who sued the state over school segregation in 2018 have accused Gov. Phil Murphy’s administration of delaying a possible resolution to integrate the state’s public schools. After years of court proceedings and almost a year and a half of failed mediated settlement talks, the case is now before state appeals court.
Desegregation court case
In recent court filings, attorneys for the families and advocates argued that New Jersey operates “egregiously segregated schools” which are harmful to students and to society. The state, which is charged with providing students with a thorough and efficient education free from segregation, has long-been aware of existing segregation and failed to prevent or remedy it, the attorneys argued in their brief.
In their most recent filing, attorneys for the state argued that the appellate court should deny the plaintiffs’ appeal. The state’s public school system does not violate the state Constitution, which requires the state to provide students with a thorough and efficient education and includes an anti-segregation clause, the attorneys argued.
A court order can help speed up integration, Orfield said, but it can also be used by politicians to stoke fear using images from the past. Most integration has happened peacefully, but the rare troubles have been widely publicized, said Orfield, who has studied the issue for decades.People are afraid of losing educational opportunities and worried integration will cost a lot of money, he said. School funding is a significant chunk of the total state budget each year and the cost of public education is the largest share of local property taxes in New Jersey.
“Any change in schools seems to be resisted by parents,” Orfield said. “Most kids are not upset by contact across racial lines these days. It’s pretty normal and pretty interesting for many students.”
Other ways to integrate
Although court orders help speed up integration, states can make progress without them, Orfield said.
“Governors and education leaders have the powers to do some good things without a court order,” Orfield said. This could mean expanding magnet schools, which are popular across the country because they expand the options available to parents, Orfield said.
About 60% of New Jersey voters said they would accept the building of regional magnet schools to promote racial integration, according to a poll conducted by Fairleigh Dickinson University last year. Slightly more than half of voters said they would be OK with mergers of adjacent school systems and 35% said they would accept transfer systems requiring schools to accept transfers from more diverse school districts, according to the poll.Mikie Sherrill, New Jersey’s next governor, plans to expand the Interdistrict Public School Choice program and county-based magnet and vocational schools.
“And she is committed to combating segregation in New Jersey’s school system head on,” said Sherrill spokesperson Sam Chan during the campaign. “She will work collaboratively with communities to expand county-based magnet, technical, and vocational schools that enroll a diverse student body and provide critical opportunities for students, especially in our urban communities.”
Support for mergers
Some New Jersey school districts have already combined to operate more efficiently, and others are studying the impacts of merging with neighboring districts.
A recent report from New America, a Washington, D.C.-based think tank, found that such mergers can increase funding fairness and decrease segregation. Researchers created three new school district maps designed to achieve greater tax base equality across the state. The “blank-slate” model starts from scratch to design district boundaries with fairness in mind. The redistricting by merger and county-based models combine already existing districts into larger districts.“These borders were not drawn because they create the best education systems,” said Zahava Stadler, one of the report’s authors who believes the borders should be redrawn to benefit the most children.
In New Jersey, strategically combining existing school districts is almost as effective as starting from scratch to create an optimized school district map, according to the report. Schools would not need to change their attendance zones under this model, which means fewer growing pains for kids and families, said Stadler, project director of New America’s Education Funding Equity Initiative.
“If you look at this with a kid’s eye view, it is an absolute no brainer that the state has a responsibility to all of its kids,” she said.
Existing inequalities
Greater tax base equality would reduce reliance on state funding in some districts, making it easier to weather unpredictability in state and federal funding.
“I’m not arguing that this is a snap your fingers kind of policy solution,” Stadler said. “However, when people tell me that it is politically difficult to change school district boundaries, my answer is that it should be a bigger political liability to underserve this many kids.”
Segregated schools produce widespread inequality since schools with high populations of students of color often have less experienced teachers, more limited curriculum and less connections to colleges and universities, Orfield said.
“It’s a multidimensional inequality because the segregation is almost always not only by race but also by concentrated poverty, which is very damaging to school opportunity,” Orfield said.
In comparison, he said desegregation has no negative effects on higher achieving students and the largest effects on low achieving students.
“Everybody gets the opportunity to learn how to live and work across racial and ethnic lines which is a tremendous asset in a diverse society,” Orfield said. “It takes courage to do but it actually does work, and it does actually produce lifelong benefits for the students.”



