Panelist Surprised By Negative Tone In Pascrell/Rothman Debate

MSU Professor Brigid Harrison said there was no clear winner in Monday's debate between Bill Pascrell and Steve Rothman.

NJ Spotlight News | May 15, 2012 | Elections

Montclair State University Professor Brigid Harrison, who was a panelist at Monday’s “Battle for the Ninth” debate between Bill Pascrell and Steve Rothman, sat down with NJ Today Managing Editor Mike Schneider to discuss the candidates.

Rothman stressed in the latest debate, and a previous one, that he is the more progressive candidate. Harrison said he was forced into calling himself a liberal. “I think he would have preferred not to do that because, of cours, that gives his general election opponent, if he were the victor, that fodder and you can see those television advertisements on that sound bite with Republicans and Independents voting in the election.”

Harrison said the term “liberal” has taken on a negative connotation. “Liberal over the years has kind of taken over a pejorative term,” she said. “So progressive kind of stands for that reformist motion but also indicates a more liberal stance on social issues.” She explained that the term progressive is equated with progress, which few would say they are opposed to.

Harrison said there wasn’t a clear winner to Monday’s debate. “I think that they were both strong and both weak on different areas,” she said. “I think that certainly Congressman Pascrell was very, very forceful in his remarks, very passionate, whereas Congressman Rothman kind of stayed on script and beat away at his talking points.”

Harrison said Rothman painted himself as the Democrats’ Democrat and kept Pascrell on the defensive during the debate.

“I think that one of the things that we saw was also a generational difference between the two,” she said. “Congressman Pascrell talked about here’s how I got to these positions and I’m not going to go and toe the party line if it violates my conscience and my principles, whereas Congressman Rothman kind of stuck to the dogmatic line and said this is where I stand and I’m consistent with the president. So I think for voters it did give them a very valuable piece of information depending on where their own beliefs lie.”

Pascrell and Rothman were good friends before Rothman announced he would be running against Pascrell in the ninth district. Harrison said while she isn’t too surprised the two are running for the same position, the tone of the campaigns has been a surprise.

“I am surprised at the negative tenor. I thought particularly because they were friends, they had served exactly the same tenure in the House, that it would be more of a kind of noble contest, more about getting out supporters rather than attacking the other guy,” she said. “And in many ways it really is unfortunate because it reflects kind of a decline in civility in our political rhetoric.”

Harrison agreed that campaigns are designed to win and those hired are meant to get results, but she said that could be part of the problem. “That professionalization of politics that you’re talking about is really responsible for kind of that decline in civility and they can blame their consultants rather than taking personal responsibility,” she said.

The negative attacks could backfire, however, according to Harrison. She said that sometimes voters hear all the negativity and decide to stay home on election day. “It’s all about turnout. This race in particular,” she said. “…They depend on primary voter turnout and this year without a competitive Democratic primary for the presidential nomination, what we’re seeing is essentially these seats will be determined in the June primary and turnout may be quite low.”


WATCH VIDEO:

Related: NJTV Presents Battle For The 9th: Pascrell/Rothman Primary Debate