In one Essex County community, officials are bringing back a decades-old neighborhood watch program to combat what they claim is rising crime. But it’s not coming without controversy.
Nutley officials have announced that the neighborhood watch program would be re-started in the face of crime and bail reforms that they said have put residents and businesses at greater risk. Essex County has seen an increasing number of vocal critics linking the social justice movement to an uptick in illegal activity, like car thefts, even as public safety data shows that crime rates are actually down since bail reforms took effect.
Anthony Manna of the Essex County Chiefs of Police said the program will assign streets and neighborhoods with watch “captains” and ask residents to stay alert to — but not engage with — anyone they think looks suspicious.
“We’re partnering with our neighbors, our residents here,” he said. “Because the more eyes we have on the street, when you see something, say something.”
But Alexander Shalom, senior supervising attorney at ACLU New Jersey, said the program could prove problematic.
“The concern with neighborhood watches is that you have untrained folks who can’t identify the difference between someone borrowing a friend’s car and someone stealing a car,” he said, “and [they] wind up trying to play police officer when we have trained people who should be doing that.”


