Lawmakers Want to Close Corporate Tax Loophole

NJ Spotlight News | February 2, 2016 | Politics

By Erin Delmore
Correspondent

Faced with a budget shortfall, a group of Democratic senators say closing a corporate tax loophole could pad New Jersey’s budget by $200 million a year.

“Clearly, there are a mix of major, major companies who are taking advantage of these loopholes,” said Sen. Paul Sarlo.

Here’s the problem as they see it. Multi-state corporations operate in New Jersey, but they plant their headquarters elsewhere: places where there are no corporate taxes, like other states or even abroad. This allows them to tuck revenue earned in New Jersey into total profits. And the senators say New Jersey is missing out on its cut.

“…Being very unfair to all taxpayers and other businesses who abide by all the rules,” said Sen. Raymond Lesniak.

But would that chase business away from New Jersey? Twenty-five states already require “combined reporting.” Almost all of New Jersey’s largest employers already operate in those states. One liberal think tank says that means business as usual for the corporations.

“Our research clearly shows that most of New Jersey’s largest employers already operate in combined-reporting states and in some cases, have been doing so for decades,” said Shelia Reynertson of New Jersey Policy Perspective.

Big businesses with big cash, the likes of Verizon and AT&T, Toys R Us and Bed Bath & Beyond, Target, Walmart and CVS. Not to mention New Jersey’s multi-billion dollar pharmaceutical industry. According to NJPP, all of the state’s largest pharma and biotech companies operate in combined reporting states.

The proposed $160 billion merger between Pfizer and Allergen is currently under a magnifying glass for potential corporate tax avoidance.

“So we’re trying to capture some of the revenue, some of the taxes, that, are not being paid here in New Jersey, because these very, very large, complicated companies and they way they’re organized have the ability to create these tax havens and shelter some of this revenue,” Sarlo said.

Lesniak calls Exxon the “worst offender.”

“New Jersey’s corporate business tax is 9 percent, right Sen. Sarlo? Their effective rate over the last five years is 2.4 percent,” he said.

He says the remainder is due to New Jersey and the scheme shorts small business owners, who have all their profits taxed since they operate in-state, there’s nowhere to shelter the profits.

“The pizzeria in Jersey City, the toy store in downtown Princeton, the software developer and photographer in Elizabeth, these folks don’t have the ability to hide their revenue in a subsidiary in another state,” said Jerome Montes of the New Jersey Main Street Alliance. “They don’t, they don’t do that. The taxes they pay and the profits they make go right back to support the communities in which they sell and offer their goods and services.”

With an estimated budget shortfall in the tens of billions of dollars, to say the state needs the cash is an understatement. Unlike last year, the senators pledged they won’t run out of time to get the bill on the governor’s desk. If he signs it, they say the additional revenue could be making its way back into the state’s coffers by fiscal year ’18.