Judge Won’t Have Decision on Same-Sex Marriage Before September

Judge Mary Jacobson heard arguments that this summer's U.S. Supreme Court decisions have changed the landscape and New Jersey's civil unions are inadequate for gay couples.

NJ Spotlight News | August 15, 2013 | Law & Public Safety

By Chief Political Correspondent Michael Aron
NJ Today

Judge Mary Jacobson heard the attorney for six gay couples and a gay organization argue that one of this summer’s U.S. Supreme Court decisions has changed the landscape.

Every day, he said, same sex couples who are not married are denied more than 1,000 federal rights and benefits.

“They go to issues like health care, domestic support, tax benefits, the right to be buried together, survivor annuities, welfare, family and medical leave as I’ve mentioned, loans, VA benefits,” Lawrence Lustberg, the attorney for the gay couples, said.

The plaintiffs want the judge to immediately declare same-sex marriage legal in New Jersey and end this two-year-old court case.

They say the current setup allowing civil unions is unequal.

“People who live and work and pay taxes here need to be treated equally,” Daniel Weiss of Asbury Park said.

“At this point it seems utterly ridiculous that it is not just common sense,” said plaintiff Cindy Meneghin.

The Christie administration is defending the current scheme.

The state attorney general’s office told the judge a declaration of unconstitutionality would be premature and questioned whether the state even has jurisdiction when it comes to federal benefits.

“Just because there is a remedy to a wrong doesn’t mean this court has the power to impose that remedy on the state,” Assistant Attorney General Kevin Jespersen said.

The judge asked challenging questions of both sides.

The plaintiff’s attorney said he came away optimistic.

“I just don’t think that a court at the end of the day is going to buy the argument that we need to wait until we know what’s going to happen with every single of those over 1,000 benefits and with regard to every single plaintiff,” said Lustberg.

The legislature has passed a gay marriage bill but Gov. Chris Christie vetoed it and said put the question on the ballot.

The organization Garden State Equality is predicting a veto override this year or a victory in court — success through either legislation or litigation, as they like to say.

“Why should they be treated as second class citizens? Why is the state of New Jersey in the practice of creating a second class citizenship for its LGBT population?” Troy Stevenson of Garden State Equality asked.

“The word marriage holds weight, and I hope the courts understand that,” Diane Marini of Collingswood said.

“No judge or justice has the morale or constitutional authority to change the definition of marriage or family,” said John Tomicki of Coalition for the Protection of Marriage.

Judge Jacobson said she’d have no decision until September at the earliest. Whichever way she rules, an appeal from the losing side is a strong possibility, so the struggle over same-sex marriage in New Jersey will go on.