Appeals court orders end of Paterson police takeover

NJ attorney general’s office has challenged the decision

Joanna Gagis, Senior Correspondent | December 18, 2024 | Law & Public Safety

A panel of state appeals court judges has ordered the New Jersey attorney general’s office to end its takeover of the Paterson Police Department and return control of the department back to the city.

The appellate court found the Attorney General’s office did not have the authority to take over the department, in a decision that raises questions over what authority the state does have to take control over local departments in the future.

The judges did make one exception in their order, allowing the state and county takeover of Paterson’s internal affairs division to continue.

“This decision is a victory for local governance and the city of Paterson,” Paterson Mayor Andre Sayegh said in a statement. “As a twice duly elected Mayor of Paterson, I have always maintained that the Attorney General’s takeover was both illegal and unconstitutional. This ruling reaffirms our city’s authority to manage its own police department and sets up a precedent for all municipalities across NJ that the responsibility of the police department rests on the local officials elected by the people.”

The order doesn’t take effect immediately and allows a three-day grace period for the any challenge of the decision to be filed to the New Jersey Supreme Court. The attorney general’s office has done just that, asking the high court to pause the change while they appeal the case.

State Attorney General Matt Platkin said in a statement that the state has spent millions on the Paterson Police Department since taking over and touted a drop in crime in the city since then.

“For decades, supersession has allowed both Attorneys General and County Prosecutors to directly manage law enforcement agencies when the circumstances call for it — as they did in Paterson when our office stepped in following a fundamental breakdown of community trust,” Platkin said. “We remain deeply committed to Paterson and to the crucial work of making the City safer for all its people, including as this wrongful decision is appealed.”

WATCH 4:12