
Clean water’s triumph meets modern woes
Millions of people, countless plants and animals live in the threatened Delaware River Watershed
This article is part of a series: “Water’s Edge: Trials and tributaries of the Delaware River Watershed.” Register here for a free, virtual roundtable on March 1.
New Jersey’s watersheds deliver drinking water to millions of people, a testament to those areas, which experts and advocates say are the most undervalued and hardest-working natural systems affecting the well-being of the public.
A healthy watershed provides a wide range of benefits. It improves water quality by filtering out pollutants. It controls erosion and sedimentation. It reduces widespread flooding. All those costs would otherwise be incurred by taxpayers, ratepayers and others.
In general, watersheds are land areas that channel rainfall and sometimes snowmelt to creeks, streams and rivers, eventually flowing into larger sources of water, such as reservoirs, bays and the ocean. Typically, they are separated from other watersheds by slopes or hills.

In the nation’s most densely populated state, but one relatively blessed with ample water resources, New Jersey’s watersheds too often suffer from many of the same ills affecting a modern 21st century economy: excess use of fertilizers, climate change, rapid urban growth and destruction of undeveloped land.
Those problems extend to many watersheds, including the major ones serving the Delaware River. They not only affect water quality, but can impact endangered species, including species like the Atlantic sturgeon and threatened species like the Pine Barrens treefrog and the saltmarsh sparrow.
Forgetting how foul the Delaware River once was
Spurred by the Clean Water Act five decades ago, once foul rivers like the Delaware were cleaned to the point that many forgot just how polluted they had been.
In “Water’s Edge: Trials and tributaries of the Delaware River Watershed,” NJ Spotlight News examines the Delaware River Watershed, detailing the problems it faces and some of the solutions government agencies and community groups are working on — or hoping to get in place.
Up in the Highlands region of the watershed, among the cleanest and least developed areas, development, stormwater runoff, failing septic tanks, fertilizer runoff and other issues create harmful algal blooms and have raised the temperature of the Musconetcong River, a tributary of the Delaware, to levels almost too high for some fish to survive.
In the urban estuary near Camden, sewage treatment plants continue to pump waste into the river and some environmentalists say the Delaware River Basin Commission needs to set tougher standards to make the river habitable for fish, including the endangered Atlantic sturgeon.
‘We are seeing a lot of development, it’s the reason we are seeing our waters degraded.’
— Mike Pisauro, The Watershed Institute
In South Jersey, efforts to preserve the sensitive Pinelands region that began 40 years ago may be waning under development pressures. There too, higher temperatures and fertilizer runoff threaten the cranberry bogs that produce New Jersey’s bountiful harvests.
And along the southern Delaware Bayshore, climate change threatens unique forests and critical habitats as saltwater intrusion continues to increase. That imperils plants, animals and the fresh drinking water supply to parts of South Jersey.
Mixed efforts, mixed results
New Jersey’s efforts to protect its many watersheds to date have resulted in mixed results, at best, experts say. In areas with the highest grades of water quality, conditions are degrading; where water quality is the lowest, they are improving, according to Mike Pisauro, policy director of The Watershed Institute, based in Pennington.
To some, the mixed results reflect the too-little attention to managing those watersheds over the past few decades.
“We are seeing a lot of development, it’s the reason we are seeing our waters degraded,” Pisauro said. “As we continue to develop, are we going to drill a few more holes in a sinking boat?”
For planning, regulatory and restoration purposes, the state Department of Environmental Protection has consolidated the hundreds of sub-watersheds in New Jersey into 20 watershed management areas in five so-called water regions.
“They tend to share the same geology, the same soils and things like that, and therefore the same issues,’’ explained Kati Angarone, associate commissioner for science and policy at DEP.
In the areas where water quality is getting worse, most of the blame is placed on nonpoint pollution — pollution associated with runoff and other dispersed sources — which virtually all agree is the biggest problem affecting all New Jersey’s watersheds. With increased development, runoff from storms picks up oil, metals and grease from paved areas, and fertilizer and pesticides from residential lawns and agricultural areas, all of which ends up in waterways.
“This has been going on for decades,’’ said Daniel Van Abs, a professor at Rutgers School of Environmental and Biological Sciences. Van Abs was referring to the degradation of what had been much-improved quality waters and also to other areas where significant improvements have been seen. Those areas, referred to as C-1 waters, are given the highest levels of protection, a policy aimed at preventing new loss in water quality.
Industrial and sewage treatment
In areas where water quality has improved, it is largely a reflection of the billions of dollars of investment spent by the state and federal governments to reduce industrial and sewage treatment plant discharges, mostly in urban and more populated areas.

With a renewed focus on protecting and restoring its watersheds, particularly in the 20 major watershed management areas, the state is adopting a different approach to how it manages watershed areas and the varied problems associated with degrading water quality.
For the most part, the best practices used there involve so-called green infrastructure designed to absorb stormwater as near as possible to where rain falls, using plant and soil systems along with permeable pavement and other permeable surfaces to try to reduce runoff to surface waters and sewer systems.
In general, that also means trying to disconnect runoff from the paved areas where it tends to collect and divert it to vegetated areas where it can be absorbed more readily into the ground, according to Vince Mazzei, an assistant commissioner for watershed and land management at the DEP.
Why the skepticism?
However, clean-water advocates remain skeptical, and, in some cases, pessimistic. “We will know within five years whether green infrastructure is moving the needle,’’ said Pisauro, of The Watershed Institute. “We’re seeing a lot of new development, some of it not managing stormwater.’’
“Last summer showed us very clearly that water doesn’t abide by political boundaries,” Angarone said, referring to the widespread flooding in the wake of Tropical Storm Ida in September 2021.
We don’t have the regulations that tell municipalities to reduce the pollution loads that impact water quality.’
— Bill Kibler, Raritan Headwaters Association
Decisions allowing development are made at the municipal level and do not account for problems that might occur in neighboring towns or downstream when building is allowed with impervious surfaces that prevent water from being absorbed into the ground.
“Most of the roads became rivers,’’ said Mazzei, recalling the storm that dumped more than eight inches of rain in some areas of New Jersey within two to three hours, an event some argued showed the need to overhaul the state’s stormwater management system.
Compounding the problem has been a lack of regulation over development in sensitive areas.
“One of the biggest challenges is we have developed in areas where growth should have not occurred, including areas too close to the water,’’ said Bill Kibler, policy director for the Raritan Headwaters Association, a nonprofit working to improve parts of the Raritan Water region. “Developers have used affordable housing to browbeat towns into approving projects where [they] should not go.’’
Better decision-making in offing?
The DEP hopes to improve land-use decisions by shifting some permitting programs — stormwater management, stormwater discharges for municipalities, and industrial discharges — into the watershed division headed by Mazzei.

It is a move backed by Kibler, who says the assistant commissioner understands watersheds and the science. “The land-use people did not understand what a watershed is,’’ Kibler said.
In some cases, new regulations may be required, Van Abs predicted.
“We don’t have the regulations that tell municipalities to reduce the pollution loads that impact water quality,’’ he added. “We are talking about regulations that affect thousands of stormwater systems.’’
Jeff Tittel, a former director of the New Jersey chapter of the Sierra Club, agreed.
“We haven’t yet melded land use management and water quality decisions,’’ he said, citing the DEP’s approval earlier this year to the building of a new natural gas compressor near the banks of the Monksville Reservoir.
Looming warehouses
To some, it points to the need to take a tougher stand on new projects impacting water quality. “Right now, we have a baker’s dozen of warehouse projects around the state that have real water quality impacts,’’ said Doug O’Malley, director of Environment New Jersey. The DEP needs to close regulatory loopholes that allow these projects to move forward, he said.
DEP argues the reorganization of some land-use management issues will result in better decisions on projects that could adversely impact water quality from advancing, in part because of improved access to water-quality monitoring data.
A larger unanswered question is how the department will address problems caused by previous poor decisions about development. Or, as Pisauro asked, “How do we address the sins of the past?’’
‘How do we address the sins of the past?’
— Mike Pisauro, The Watershed Institute
Until now, the DEP has focused primarily on new projects and how they affect water quality. “We don’t have that luxury anymore,’’ Mazzei said. Instead, the agency plans to review new proposals to redevelop old sites and require them to meet new standards for reducing adverse water-quality impacts, he said.
For example, Mazzei suggested redevelopment of former industrial sites may not occur over the entire property and instead more permeable areas to reduce runoff from the site could be required. “We need to undo those impacts from the past,’’ he acknowledged.
While clean-water advocates generally embrace the new policies being pushed by the DEP, they still have doubts whether the state is moving in the right direction.
“There is a big mismatch of the resources to the magnitude of the problem,’’ Van Abs said.
“The jury is still out,’’ Kibler said. “The two defining issues are climate change and development,’’ he added. How the state responds to those huge challenges is likely to determine whether the Clean Water Act’s goal of making waters swimmable and fishable will ever be achieved.
— Colleen O’Dea contributed to this story.
This article is part of a special series by NJ Spotlight News and funded by the William Penn Foundation. The project homepage is your roadmap to the series. Send us your stories and photos about the Delaware River region.
