How K-12 schools are funded in New Jersey has been a hot-button issue for decades, with money that pays for education a significant portion of both the total state budget and local property tax bills.
The leading candidates for governor have different plans for updating the school funding formula, which they plan to pursue if elected.
Republican Jack Ciattarelli said his version of the formula would distribute funding to students based on if they already speak English or are English language learners. There would be no additional money for low-income students. The state would also pay for the cost of special education in local schools, a significant cost for districts.
Democrat Mikie Sherrill’s plan is lighter on details and focuses on what the campaign calls modernizing and stabilizing the current formula to limit swings in how much state funding a district receives from year to year. She also wants the state to do more to address rising costs of special education.
Despite what candidates promise voters, changing the formula is not so easy. The current formula became law in 2008, with revisions in 2018, and is the first to be deemed constitutional by the state Supreme Court. Changes must be approved by the state Senate and Assembly, and a new formula would likely be challenged in court.
How the formula works
The state’s current school funding law is calculated using a base amount needed to educate a single student. That base amount is also determined by the formula. More money is added for students from low-income households and English language learners. Additional funding is provided for students with learning disabilities based on the average percentage of students with disabilities in the state.
School districts raise funds through local property taxes to pay for public education. Districts are advised, but not required, to raise local property taxes up to the “local fair share” — the amount a district can contribute locally as calculated by the formula. The state gives districts the money needed to cover the gap between the local fair share and the amount required for an “adequate” education, as calculated by the formula. State funds, known as “equalization aid,” are distributed proportionally to a community’s wealth, with the bulk of it going to lower-income areas that cannot raise as much money through property taxes.Some districts that have not raised taxes to meet that local fair share now face budget shortfalls that cannot be closed by tax increases or increases in state aid. Districts face a 2% cap on school-tax increases, under a law signed by former Gov. Chris Christie after the aid formula was in place.
The formula is only in its second year of being fully funded after a state law passed in 2018 led to a gradual phase in of full funding of direct aid to schools. Some aid categories, such as extraordinary special education aid, are still not fully funded under the formula.
School budgets are largely funded by state and local taxes, but federal funding is used to cover some services, including additional support for students with disabilities and low-income students.
Ciattarelli’s plan
If Ciattarelli is elected governor, he said he wants to simplify the formula to include just two base pupil amounts – one for English speakers and another for English learners. Funding would be limited to between $15,000 and $20,000 per student in every district, not including special education costs. Some urban districts with higher populations of low-income students would see significant cuts because of this plan.
Districts that currently receive less state aid often have better educational outcomes than districts receiving more state aid, Ciattarelli said. Under the current formula, more state money flows to low-income districts that can’t raise as much locally.
Existing research supports giving additional funding to at-risk and low-income students who need extra support, like the current formula does, said Danielle Farrie, research director at the Education Law Center. Ciattarelli’s proposal “would create enormous inequities within our school funding formula and really do a major disservice to students,” Farrie said.
Under his plan, the state would pick up the bill for special education, which makes up a large chunk of school district budgets. In the 2023-24 school year, students with disabilities made up about 19% of students in New Jersey.
Sherrill’s plan
Sherrill also plans to increase support for special education students, with a focus on addressing the rising cost of extraordinary special education funding for students with high-cost needs.
She would focus on ensuring the formula properly accounts for schools with a higher percentage of special education students, according to campaign spokesperson Sam Chan. Currently, special education funding is distributed to districts based on the average percent of special education students in the state.
Sherrill said she aims to “stabilize and modernize” the formula, limiting swings in state aid from one year to the next. She committed to fully funding the formula if elected.
Not just the candidates
For either candidate’s plans to become reality, they would need the support of state lawmakers. A bill sponsored by state Sen. Vin Gopal (D-Monmouth), who is Sherrill’s campaign chairman, would make changes to the funding formula. It passed the Senate but is yet to come up for a vote in the Assembly Education Committee. Action on the bill is unlikely until after the gubernatorial election.If changes do become law, it’s likely the new formula would face legal challenges to determine it’s constitutionality.
Gov. Phil Murphy made some changes to the funding formula for the current fiscal year through the state’s budget, but the changes will expire at the end of June. The next governor could choose to make changes in a similar manner, although they would still need support from state lawmakers who must pass the state budget. Changes made through budget language are only temporary.
— Julie O’Connor and Joanna Gagis contributed reporting.




