Camden parents dissatisfied, urge end to state takeover of city’s public schools

Parents air frustrations with lack of improvement, lack of transparency

Hannah Gross, Education and Child Welfare Writer | September 15, 2025 | Education

Credit: (P. Kenneth Burns/WHYY)
Camden High School

More than a decade after the state takeover of Camden City School District, enrollment in traditional public schools has dropped as charter and renaissance schools have become increasingly popular.

Most Camden students now attend charter and renaissance schools, which are like charters but are financed differently and follow different rules. Over half of the district’s budget for the 2024-25 school year was spent on tuition for charter and renaissance schools, former Superintendent Katrina McCombs told the State Board of Education in June.

WATCH 5:08
Parents are frustrated with what they see as a lack of progress since the 2013 takeover, prompting them to urge members of the State Board of Education to return the district to local control at a meeting on Wednesday.

Residents who testified said declining enrollment, funding and resources for traditional public schools have hurt student outcomes and opportunities. The school district made deep cuts ahead of this school year to close a $91 million deficit, including cuts to family operations coordinators. Without these positions, residents said there is a lack of communication and transparency about what is going on in the district, including the hiring of a new superintendent.

Worse, not better

“State intervention in Camden schools was meant to bring improvement. To many in our community, those conditions have worsened, especially after budget cuts removed family engagement coordinators,” said Carla Villegas, a mother of a student in the district.

McCombs left the school district at the end of June after seven years as superintendent to become assistant commissioner for the Division of Early Childhood Services within the New Jersey Department of Education. State officials are searching for a new superintendent, who will be appointed by the education commissioner without input from the Camden school advisory board.

‘We’re scared of Camden public schools shrinking so rapidly that we will be left with no traditional public schools.’ — Ronsha Dickerson, executive director, Camden Parent & Student Union

Davida Coe-Brockington, former principal of Creative Arts High School, is acting superintendent. A new superintendent is expected to start on Nov. 1. Typically, elected local school board members are charged with hiring superintendents, but because of the state takeover the decision is up to the state.

To get input on hiring the superintendent, the district shared a survey for families, staff and students. The process is now in the interview and finalist-selection phase, according to a timeline given on the district’s website.

‘Weakened trust, reduced family involvement’

Several parents and advocates who testified before the state board said family engagement is more critical than ever as the district prepares to bring on a new superintendent.

Local and state education board meetings can be hard to access, said Lena Toledo, a data manager at Parents Invincible, a Camden group that advocates for parent engagement and school choice. She asked that people be allowed to testify virtually, to accommodate people who can’t attend in person.

The State Board of Education meets each month in Trenton and listens to public testimony on any topic three times a year, including in September. Parents and advocates traveled from Camden to voice their concerns during the public testimony portion of the meeting.

To close the district’s $91 million deficit, Camden City School District reduced full-time staff from about 1,618 to 1,331.

“Without [family operations coordinators], parents go left out and teachers are stretched thin trying to fill the gap,” said Villegas, an organizer manager for Parents Invincible. “This loss has weakened trust and reduced family involvement at a time where engagement is critical.”

Most of the Camden residents testified before board member Jack Fornaro and Vice President Nedd James Johnson, who said the concerns would be shared with the rest of the State Board of Education. Two other board members listened to the testimony from another room.

Wednesday was not the first time Camden residents brought their concerns to the board. In June, when McCombs, the former superintendent, provided the board with an annual report on the school district, students held a rally outside of the New Jersey Department of Education building to express their concerns about recent budget cuts.

Big deficit, big staff cuts

To close the district’s $91 million deficit, Camden City School District reduced full-time staff from about 1,618 to 1,331, McCombs told the state board in June. Many of these cuts were in support-staff roles.

Kevin Waters, a recently retired high school crisis counselor in the district, said these roles are critical and must be restored.

“As a therapist and a counselor myself, those individuals who were let go, were a part of a function to help in the way of providing students supports,” he said. “Those individuals on some level need to be able to come back.”

Ronsha Dickerson, executive director of the Camden Parent & Student Union, urged the State Board of Education to audit the school district’s budget and visit some of the schools. Dickerson sent seven children through schools in the district, where her husband works as a teacher.

“We’re scared of Camden public schools shrinking so rapidly that we will be left with no traditional public schools,” she said.