Op-Ed: We must face New Jersey’s affordable housing crisis

Many people struggle to find an affordable place to live even though they are working

Paul Shackford | August 26, 2025 | Opinion, Housing

Paul Shackford

I’ve been involved with addressing housing and food insecurity in Bergen County for over 35 years. Early on, I spoke to a group of 200 people in one town about working with local houses of worship to provide overnight temporary shelter for homeless adults. My colleagues and I were drowned out by residents yelling that we were going to ruin their town. They were afraid.

Today, many people still are.

Recently, I and others from Family Promise of Bergen County spoke to the land use board in the Borough of Emerson about providing eight units of temporary housing for families who otherwise might become homeless. Over the course of four public meetings, it became clear to me that many of the most vocal residents and all but one member of the land use board had already made up their minds. Some residents who spoke at the meeting objected to our request for a variance that was needed to convert a vacant commercial building. They claimed the possibility of up to eight homeless children would “ruin their schools,” and that our families would make illegal left-hand turns into and out of the parking lot.

Yet the residents’ fears were based on stereotypes and misinformation, not fact.

Our mission at Family Promise is to help working families with children deal with homelessness. The families who come to us in crisis are at imminent risk of homelessness or have become homeless. We provide temporary housing and wraparound support services where parents work to build their own long-term solutions. We help the single mom who loses her job after missing work to care for her sick child. We help the parent working two full-time jobs who can’t afford to fix a broken-down car. Countless real-life events, like these, push families to the brink of losing their housing.

Some of the working poor in Bergen County might be “fortunate” to only have to pay $1,200 or so for a studio or one-bedroom apartment. But if they cannot pay the rent for a month and are evicted, they probably will never find another apartment for that rent in Bergen County.

According to the National Low Income Housing Coalition, across New Jersey there is a shortage of more than 205,000 “affordable and available” units for extremely low-income renters. And if they do find housing within their price range, most landlords will not rent to them because of the eviction on their record.

In his book “There is No Place for Us: Working and Homeless in America,” author Brian Goldstone describes families caught in this trap. They are working, often more than one job, yet struggle to pay the rent.

Who are these people? You see them, and maybe even talk with them, every day — the cashier scanning your groceries, the fast-food worker handling your meals, the restaurant server and the bartender, the gas station attendant and the car washer. Even some teachers in your local schools are living on the edge.

One reason we at Family Promise try to avoid using the “H” word — homeless — is because it often shuts down listening. It conjures up images of jobless individuals sleeping on city streets. But far more of those caught up in this crisis are working and yet struggle to find affordable housing.

Many of these folks are parents with young children. Some sleep in their cars. Others double up with friends or relatives until they are told to leave, because an apartment meant for one family rarely works for two. Sadly, children in these families will carry the physical and emotional scars of this crisis for the rest of their lives if nothing changes.

The issue, quite simply, is a lack not just of housing, but of affordable housing. Just drive through the towns and cities in Bergen County and you will see a lot of housing being constructed. Yet very little of it will be for those who are poor — New Jersey fair housing legislation requires developers to create only a small percentage of affordable units (typically only 15% to 20%) per new project.

It’s a vicious circle. The costly new apartment complexes we are building eat up space that could be used for affordable housing.

We need to face it. This problem — the lack of enough affordable housing for all — is not going to go away unless we face it and solve it.

Why don’t we? Because it’s hard. It’s costly. And it’s easier to just look the other way and use our tax dollars to repave our streets and improve our airports. Life is so much easier if we don’t see what’s happening to so many in our communities.

But our life is poorer for that, too. So I urge you to look around, be a voice of support for affordable housing proposals where you live. Imagine living in a county that actively addresses this issue. We will all be better off if we do.

For more information about Family Promise, please visit  www.bergenfamilypromise.org.