New report shows sweeping impact of GOP’s deep health care cuts

Trump, Republicans want tax cuts. To pay for that, health care, education, social safety net must get slashed

Benjamin J. Hulac, Washington Correspondent | May 8, 2025 | Healthcare, Budget

Credit: (AP Photo/Thibault Camus)
File photo

WASHINGTON — Millions of low-income Americans would lose their health insurance under proposals Republicans are considering for a massive bill that could bring deep cuts to federal social, health, food and education programs.

That behemoth bill is working its way through Congress as Republicans look for ways to pay for the Trump administration’s agenda, in particular tax cuts.

After Republicans adopted a budget plan last month, committees on Capitol Hill have been writing different portions of that broader bill, with the goal of stitching them all together, clearing the House and Senate and eventually reaching the White House for the president’s signature.

Overall, Republicans aim to cut domestic spending by trillions of dollars to pay for tax cuts, mostly for high-income earners and corporations.

Many portions of this broad bill are not public, including the portion about health care programs including Medicaid.

But Republicans have floated ideas of how to cut spending from federal health care programs, and the Congressional Budget Office, a nonpartisan agency that provides economic research for lawmakers, analyzed five proposals to Medicaid and projected what would happen if they became law.

WATCH 4:09
Between 8.6 million and 2.3 million people enrolled in Medicaid, a federal health insurance program for low-income patients, would be removed from the program over the next decade, the CBO said in its analysis, made public Wednesday.

About 1.9 million people are enrolled in Medicaid in New Jersey, where the program pays for 30% of births in the state and nearly two-thirds of nursing home residents. In New Jersey, Medicaid goes by the name NJ Family Care.

New Jersey officials anticipate receiving about $14.8 billion through Medicaid in the state budget year that begins July 1, including nearly $544 million state officials intend to use as hospital aid.

Modeling state Medicaid officials conducted this year indicates changes under discussion in Congress could cost the state from $2.2 billion to nearly $10 billion every year.

The CBO director sent the report to lawmakers on the Senate and House committees that oversee medical policy, including Rep. Frank Pallone (D-6th), the highest-ranking Democrat on Energy and Commerce, which writes health care law.

”This non-partisan Congressional Budget Office analysis confirms what we’ve been saying all along: Republicans’ Medicaid proposals result in millions of people losing their health care,” Pallone said in a statement Wednesday.

A proposal to limit the amount of federal money states that expanded Medicaid through the Affordable Care Act, a 2010 law commonly called Obamacare, would remove 5.5 million people nationwide from coverage, the CBO said.

Under current law, the federal government pays a “blended rate” of about 60% of all New Jersey Medicaid costs, according to state officials, although the FMAP, or federal match, for various patient groups ranges from 50% for most members to 90% for those who signed up through the expansion that the 2010 health law allowed. Eliminating the 90% match for these expansion members would cost New Jersey $2.3 billion in the first year, according to state modeling.

Pallone’s committee was scheduled this week to debate and vote on its portion of the bill, which would affect Medicaid, but postponed that hearing until next week.

Speaker Mike Johnson, a Louisiana Republican who sets the agenda in the House, has a narrow political tightrope to walk to pass the large bill. Depending on how many members are present for a vote, Johnson can spare losing as few as two Republicans and still pass a bill. Johnson, who must corral hard-right members who want deep spending cuts with more moderate Republicans broadly supportive of a softer approach, told reporters Tuesday night that the idea of cutting the state match for Medicaid was no longer under consideration.

In the Senate, where Republicans hold a 53-47 majority, the number Republicans can lose is four since Vice President JD Vance can break 50-50 tie votes.

Another proposal the CBO analyzed would limit the tax states charge doctors and hospitals to pay for Medicaid costs. That would save $880 million over the next decade and remove 8.6 people from Medicaid.

New Jersey assesses fees on hospital services, outpatient surgery and certain health insurance plans to help offset the state’s share of Medicaid costs. These fees generated $1.6 billion in the current budget year, money that attracts some $3.3 billion in matching funds annually, according to state data.

Other ideas CBO assessed include limiting federal spending on Medicaid overall; limiting federal spending on Medicaid per person enrolled in the program; and repealing a federal rule meant to encourage enrollment.

Republican leaders set a goal of cutting $880 in federal spending over the next decade from programs under the purview of Pallone’s committee.

That would not be possible without cutting deep into Medicaid, the CBO said in March.

Republicans are also considering language to add what are known as “work requirements” — that physically capable people who receive Medicaid coverage have jobs.

In a recent interview with NJ Spotlight News, Rep. Jeff Van Drew (R-2nd) said analysis his office completed showed it’s possible to reach the Republicans’ $880 billion target with three changes — requiring enrollees to show they are eligible every six months, a tighter timeline than the current 12-month requirement; work requirements; and removing undocumented people from the rolls.

“You can get damn close to it,” Van Drew said.

“I didn’t just trust the speaker’s office,” he said. “I had my team analyze it, go through it.”

Van Drew said he’d vote for legislation that got close, say $780 billion or $800 billion in cuts, to that $880 billion target.

Asked to share that analysis, a Van Drew spokeswoman, Paxton Antonucci, declined to do so.

During negotiations on the underlying legislation, Van Drew has emerged as a more moderate voice among Republicans in the House, pushing for softer cuts than those on the hard-right.

“We will not vote for a reconciliation that takes benefits away from eligible, legal entities, whether they be individual people or whether it be a hospital, whatever that case that actually takes away from the disabled, the working poor, senior citizens,” Van Drew said. “I don’t want a mean bill. I don’t want to hurt people.”