NJ’s voting system is secure. Here’s why

Unsupported claims may be causing ‘irreparable damage’

Colleen O'Dea, Senior Writer and Projects Editor | November 1, 2024 | NJ Decides 2024, Politics

Credit: (Colleen O'Dea/NJ Spotlight News)
At a training session in February on the New Jersey voting system, Beth Thompson (left) of the Hunterdon County Board of Elections explains how to use voting machines and Hunterdon County Clerk Mary Melfi (right) explains the vote-by-mail process.

In 2016, Donald Trump ran for president, won the Electoral College vote but lost the popular vote to Hillary Clinton by 2.9 million votes. He started almost immediately sowing doubt about those results and continued to do so through his term in the White House.

The election denial movement he fomented grew in 2020, when Trump lost to President Joe Biden and never conceded the election. Trump’s legal team filed 63 lawsuits, all but one of which were dropped or dismissed as without merit or for lack of standing.

Trump’s baseless contentions spurred thousands to march on the Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021, to “stop the steal,” resulting in six deaths — including Jersey-born Capitol Police Officer Brian Sicknick — and more than 170 police officers injured. Close to 1,300 rioters have been charged, with about 300 sentenced to incarceration and Trump has been indicted in federal court and in Georgia for his efforts to overturn the election results.

Ever since, Trump and other Republicans across the country have continued to claim without proof that U.S. election results can’t be trusted. These claims spread widely via social media and partisan news media.

“After eight years of [President] Obama and divided government, Trump was able to seize on the discontent among many voters and usher in a new era of politics built on growing distrust, dissatisfaction, and desires for populism,” said Ashley Koning, director of the Eagleton Center for Public Interest Polling at Rutgers University. “The meteoric rise of social media within the past decade has only bolstered this, allowing for misinformation and disinformation that often bypassed the lens and discerning eye of traditional information channels.” Misinformation is defined as inaccurate information without specific malicious intent to mislead; disinformation is defined as deliberately deceptive information.

Koning added that “Trumpism and social media have worked hand in hand to discredit much of the foundation of our democracy and politicize and dismantle the institutional norms that have historically been integral parts of our political process … causing potentially irreparable damage to our democratic system — including what information we trust, the ability to make policy, and the most basic acts of voting.”

Unsupported claims live on

The unsupported claims have staying power. A poll earlier this month by the Hughes Center for Public Policy at Stockton University said 33% of New Jersey voters do not believe the 2020 election was fair and secure and that 31% have little to no confidence that votes will be accurately cast and counted this year.

“Election distrust is pretty much baked in among a certain group of voters,” said Alyssa Maurice, director of research at the William J. Hughes Center for Public Policy at Stockton University, on the release of the poll results. “Despite the lack of evidence of widespread fraud, this skepticism is not budging.”

More on NJ election security measures amid flood of misinformation

NJ Spotlight News examined the state’s election system to try to allay continuing doubts and explain how votes are cast and counted and the safeguards in the system to guarantee that elections are free and fair.

Election fraud is rare, and the few cases that have been prosecuted prove that the system is able to find attempts — and that officials do prosecute these cases. For example, the Paterson council president and three others have been charged in a case that is still pending with attempted fraud and witness tampering involving mail-in ballots during the 2020 Paterson municipal election.

Widespread mistrust

Election officials in New Jersey can attest to the pervasive mistrust of the system. They say they continue to get phone calls from members of the public questioning election processes. Officials in some counties have held events to explain the system to the public and show them the voting equipment and how it works, but some still leave with doubts.

“A fundamental part of election integrity is having the public understand and trust the process,” said Tahesha Way, New Jersey’s chief election official as secretary of state and also the lieutenant governor, during a recent news briefing on election processes and security in an effort to debunk some of the misconceptions.

“It is dangerous to our democracy when voters believe mis- or disinformation about how our elections are conducted … When we allow wrong information about our elections to undermine our confidence in the process, our trust in democracy and each other, that’s a form of voter suppression.”

Safeguarding mail-in ballots

Mail-in balloting has been the focus of a misinformation campaign nationwide that contends the process allows for widespread fraud, including people voting multiple times or submitting votes under false names.

There are safeguards in place to prevent those.

When county election officials in New Jersey receive a mail-in ballot, they scan it into the Statewide Voter Registration System to log it as a vote. That means the voter who submitted the ballot could not submit another or vote again at an in-person voting site. If they tried, they would be flagged as having already voted.

A person is only allowed to mail or drop in a drop box three ballots for others, to prevent what is called ballot harvesting, and mailing or dropping off any more than three is a crime in New Jersey. The person delivering the ballot must sign their  name and address. Ballots can be rejected if they were among a larger batch delivered by someone.

The more than 100 ballot drop boxes in New Jersey are under 24-hour video surveillance and designed to prevent someone from being able to reach in and tamper with ballots. Election officials regularly check them and remove ballots throughout the mail-in ballot period — clerks began sending mail-in ballots to voters on Sept. 21 this year.

Credit: (Colleen O'Dea/NJ Spotlight News)
A machine that scans mailed-in ballots, displayed at a training held by Hunterdon County election officials in February

Once election officials begin opening ballots, which in New Jersey can happen up to five days before Election Day — starting Thursday this year — they will check the voter’s signature on the ballot envelope against the one on file. If the signatures don’t match, officials will flag the ballot and send the voter a notice, giving them an opportunity to “cure” the ballot by proving they did fill out the ballot; that can be done through Nov. 16 this year. If the voter doesn’t respond or cannot provide proof, the ballot won’t count.

Valid ballots are separated from the envelopes containing the signatures so that the ballots remain anonymous. They are fed into scanning machines where the counts are kept secret until after the polls close at 8 p.m. on Election Day. Accessing those tallies before then is a crime in New Jersey.

Murphy-Ciattarelli

The reporting of these results has caused some to cry foul when they have seen sudden lead changes in the middle of the night after polls closed and results are being reported. That happened in the 2021 race for governor when Republican challenger Jack Ciattarelli’s small lead over Democratic incumbent Phil Murphy flipped after Bergen County, which has the most voters in the state and a majority of whom are Democrats, added mail-in ballot counts to its totals. Murphy’s final victory margin was more than 3 percentage points.

A change in a candidate’s position throughout election night or over subsequent days can be explained by the counting of mail-in ballots and when they are reported; across the country, Democrats tend to vote by mail at far greater rates than Republicans. As of the end of day Wednesday, six of every 10 mail-in ballots returned statewide were submitted by registered Democrats and numbered almost three times more than Republicans. Close to 690,000 had been returned and another 421,000 were outstanding.

It’s more time-consuming for election workers to open and scan these ballots than to get vote summaries from voting machines, so larger counties that get a lot of mail-in ballots may not report these results until late in the evening, making for lead changes as results are reported. As long as they are postmarked by Election Day, mail-in ballots received up to six days later — Nov. 12 this year in New Jersey — are still counted. That’s so postal service delays don’t disenfranchise voters. As these late mail-in ballots are added to the totals, they can wind up deciding close races.

“In some cases where an election comes down to a small number of votes, we may not know the results on election night or in the days that follow,” Way said.

She added that next Tuesday night, county officials will report votes cast early in person — more than 632,000 as of last Wednesday — and Election Day machine tallies, as well as those mail-in ballots they have been able to count. Counties will also report the number of mail-in ballots they still have to count and update that daily until all the votes are counted.

In-person voting safeguards

When voting in person, signatures are used to confirm identities.

When New Jersey began early in-person voting three years ago, it switched from a printed poll book to a system of electronic poll books that automatically log a person as having voted. This means no one can vote more than once during early voting — which ends Sunday at 6 p.m. this year — or vote by mail and then try to vote in person early or on Election Day.

Votes that are cast during the nine-day early voting period are stored electronically. No one will see the totals until these are delivered to the county clerk and reported to the public on election night. Again, trying to access these totals early is a crime in New Jersey.

The machines used in New Jersey for early and Election Day voting are not connected to the internet, so they cannot be hacked. Problems can arise — two recent ones in Mercer and Monmouth counties were due to software programming glitches — but they can be repaired quickly.

There are no substantiated cases of machines switching votes for candidates anywhere in the United States. New Jersey’s voting machines now have a verified paper trail, so in most counties that use touch-screen machines, voters see a paper that shows their choices and must affirm that they are accurate before their votes are submitted.

Because these machines have a voter-verified paper trail, vote totals can be checked in recounts. Randomized audits are also performed after each election. So far, these audits have not found any significant differences between machine totals and hand counts of paper ballots.

Challenging votes

Both the Democratic and Republican parties and candidates  can place challengers at polling locations. Challengers can question someone’s right to vote if they suspect the vote might not be cast legally, such as if a person had moved away and didn’t change their voter registration.

Overseeing all these processes are county officials and bipartisan boards of election. When there are questions about ballot signatures or improperly marked ballots, these groups of Democrats and Republicans decide which votes are proper and which to disallow. During the presidential election in 2020, more than 66,500 ballots were rejected in New Jersey, or about 1.4% of the total cast.

When there are questions about a voter’s right to cast a ballot — if a person received a mail-in ballot but didn’t use it and showed up in person or if the person’s signature does not match the one on file — a voter may be asked to fill out a paper provisional ballot. This allows the person to vote but also allows election officials to investigate and verify the voter’s identity and ensure they had not already voted.

There are also safeguards to prevent a person from being disenfranchised by not being permitted to vote.

Important hotlines

  • New Jersey has a voter information hotline — 877-NJVOTER (877-658-6837) — where people can find more information about voting and report suspected election law violations.
  • In New Jersey, voters can call 800-277-BIAS (800-277-2427) to report discrimination or harassment while trying to vote.
  • There’s also a national voter protection hotline — 866-OUR-VOTE (866-687-8683) — that can assist voters who have a problem voting.
  • The election protection hotline is also available in Spanish (888-839-8662), Arabic (844-925-5287) and a number of Asian languages (888-274-8683).
  • Superior Court judges are available in each county to hear cases involving voters during early voting and on Election Day.