Credit: (AP Photo/Paul Sancya)State lawmakers want to prevent popular driving navigation apps from suggesting motorists avoid New Jersey’s traffic jams by using side streets that may not be able to handle the increased volume.
Concerns about public safety and traffic congestion have become a big issue for many communities in northern New Jersey in recent years, including small towns located along I-95, where the highway approaches the George Washington Bridge.
Those concerns prompted legislation that advanced earlier this week through committees in both houses of the Legislature.
Knock-on gridlock
When backups occur, sponsors say apps like Waze and Google Maps use algorithms to let motorists know, in real time, about potentially faster routes — even if the alternatives will take motorists onto small side streets that themselves can quickly become gridlocked with traffic.
“Many of our towns are seeing significant congestion in residential neighborhoods and smaller roadways — areas that are not meant to handle diverted highway traffic,” said Assemblyman Clinton Calabrese (D-Bergen).
Failure to comply with the proposed law could result in fines of up to $5,000 a day for the app’s owners, according to the legislation.
“This situation can impede emergency vehicle access, lead to more accidents and negatively impact public safety,” said Calabrese, a primary sponsor of the legislation.
Studies show driving navigation apps that offer turn-by-turn directions via a smartphone are used by billions of motorists across the globe.
Some of the apps can provide motorists with updated roadway conditions, such as alerts about construction, accidents and traffic jams. And depending on motorist preferences, they can also suggest new routes to avoid things like slowdowns or highway tolls.
Unintended consequences
But sponsors of the legislation say the apps may have unintended consequences, both for the motorists using them and for those living in small communities located near major highways like I-95.
“This bill seeks to strike a balance between the benefits of technology, and the safety of our communities,” said Calabrese, who chairs the Assembly Transportation and Independent Authorities Committee.Deputy Chief Kenny Sheridan of the Ridgefield Police Department said his community is one of those seeing high volumes on small, local roads that are often triggered by the driving apps.
“These drivers are often saving only a few minutes on their trip, but at a much greater cost to public safety,” Sheridan said during a recent hearing convened by Calabrese’s committee.
“In recent years, we’ve had a significant uptick in pedestrian and bicycle accidents as a direct result of this increased traffic flow,” he said.
Getting the state involved
To address the traffic concerns, the legislation backed by Calabrese and Senate sponsor Gordon Johnson (D-Bergen) would offer municipalities the option of adopting a resolution to request a state investigation of an “emergency condition.”
From there, the request would be reviewed by both the state Department of Transportation and the attorney general’s office, with the latter agency able to order the owners of an app to detour motorists around any areas that have an “emergency condition” designation.
‘This is a very difficult thing to try to manage. The fact is, we have a lot of commuters in this state, and we have a lot of traffic.’ — Dale Florio, lobbyist on behalf of Google
Failure to comply with the proposed law would result in fines of up to $5,000 a day for an app’s owners, according to the legislation.
It’s unclear if any other states have attempted to enact laws to address similar concerns, but Dale Florio, a lobbyist who spoke on behalf of Google during a recent Senate committee hearing, raised several concerns about the proposed law.
Among them, he said the legislation, as currently drafted, would not apply to some turn-by-turn navigation systems, including those installed by manufacturers directly into an automobile’s dashboard.
A constitutional question
Those who already know local shortcuts would also still be free to travel on them whenever backups arise, Florio said.
“This is a very difficult thing to try to manage,’ he said. “The fact is, we have a lot of commuters in this state, and we have a lot of traffic.”
Meanwhile, some lawmakers also raised concerns about the constitutionality of restricting public access to what are essentially public roads.
“I don’t think government should be deciding what roads some citizens can use, and not others,” said Assemblyman Greg McGuckin (R-Ocean).
“I believe this is going to turn into a ‘legal bonanza’ if we pass it,” said Assemblyman Christian Barranco (R-Passaic).


