Op-Ed: If NJ wants more teachers, it must do more to convince young people like me

An NJ student says many teachers face a lack of respect, poor pay and poor working conditions

MiaRose Brown | July 23, 2024 | Opinion

Credit: (Courtesy of Melvin Brown)
MiaRose Brown

Editor’s note: NJ Spotlight News and Rowan University teamed up on a project this spring to amplify New Jersey’s youth voices and perspectives on important public policy topics. The project involved students in the university’s first-year writing program, each assigned to write an op-ed. This is the second of two that Rowan faculty and NJ Spotlight News chose as exemplars. (If you are a New Jersey college student and have an op-ed to share, contact jmooney@njspotlightnews.org.)

As a child, I often dreamed of becoming a teacher. My mother was a teacher for 23 years, well respected and proud of her work. She loved and was loved by her students. But when I told my mother my career goals, she would often say, “You don’t want to be a teacher, Mia.”

I always questioned that statement, considering my mother stayed in her position for as long as she did. Now, however, I both understand why she stayed but, also more than ever, why she left.

I am a junior at Rowan University, and I took my mother’s advice and now am an aspiring professional in health care. I see the lack of respect, pay, and poor working conditions that have caused teaching to become a less desirable career field.

If New Jersey truly wants young people like me to choose teaching as a career, it must make the profession more appealing. To do so, it should begin effectively advocating for higher pay and better working conditions.

For a 20-year-old like me, a key reason the teaching profession is not as desirable is a lack of respect. By respect, I mean the public treating teachers as professionals, rather than babysitters. This often begins with the relationship parents have with their children’s teachers.

As a young child, I witnessed my mother often having to hold students accountable for behavior that should have been the parents’ responsibility. COVID-19 made this problem even worse.

My mother said: “COVID has given everyone the ‘ability’ to be given a waiver on any type of disciplinary action, leaving teachers to have to maintain an instructional classroom while maintaining behavioral stability, outside normal classroom management, at the same time.”

This experience is not unique to my mother. Studies have shown a rise of behavioral and emotional setbacks specifically due to the pandemic. These behavioral challenges show no signs of lessening, and teachers are bearing the burden.

No teacher in or entering the field expects to get rich within the profession, but with inflation playing its own role in the situation, teachers are also taking on many more responsibilities and pressures, but not the compensation to match.

New Jersey is currently ranked the second highest state for starting teacher pay in the nation, at $55,143. Yet considering the high cost of living in New Jersey, that’s hardly enough. In comparison, my desired field of dental hygiene has a starting salary of around $84, 600, far above a teacher’s starting salary, despite a comparable amount of required education and training.

As you can imagine, the possibility of a career that allowed me to make a living was a significant factor in persuading me to choose a career in health care. Working as a dental hygienist will allow me to continue to work with children, a passion of mine, while still being able to support myself.

Teaching, at least at the moment, does not fulfill that financial necessity.

When I asked my mother why she left the profession, she replied, “It was certainly not the children that had brought on these feelings, but the lack of support, respect, and overall care for the teacher’s mental health that led me to this choice.”

State and local leaders need to begin advocating for higher teacher salaries and start educating communities on why teachers deserve more. We need to make the career more appealing and inviting to those who want to enter and stay in it, specifically by promoting respect for the field and improving working conditions.

When I asked my mom about her final moments as an educator she said, “A person can only take so much before they are physically, mentally and emotionally pushed to exhaustion.”

As her daughter, I hated knowing that her career of helping others became so difficult. It is important that we advocate for our current and future teachers to be treated better in all aspects. The younger generations should have the same chance at a meaningful education and great teachers like my mother.