
Bills are heard in the State House every day that have the potential to change the lives of New Jersey residents.
Recently, there was a joint Senate Environment and Energy Committee and Assembly Utilities and Telecommunications Committee hearing where Sen. Bob Smith’s 100% clean-energy bill (S-237/A-1480) was up for a discussion.
For many, the domain of energy committees might seem a distant realm from the concerns of physicians, particularly those serving in environmental justice communities. However, the truth is stark: clean energy is not merely an environmental issue; it’s fundamentally a matter of public health, impacting every corner of New Jersey.
Fossil fuel combustion adversely impacts New Jerseyans’ health, and this will only increase in the future. Steps like tighter air quality regulations from the Environmental Protection Agency are needed but we have seen that even these regulations are already being weakened. We cannot wait for federal regulations for our health.
The grim questions we face are these: How many deaths from fossil fuel pollution are too much, and how small a number is acceptable? There is no question that deaths are linked to fossil fuel pollution and climate change, but the question is just how many. Modeling pollution and climate change-related illness and death is complex, with millions of environmental, social and political variables. While some calculations point to tens of millions of deaths, estimates go into the hundreds of millions if you factor premature deaths from fossil fuel pollution. A commonly quoted, conservative estimate from the World Health Organization is that 1 in 5 premature deaths is caused by fossil fuel pollution. In New Jersey, 17,600 deaths annually are directly linked to air pollution, based on research from the Harvard School of Public Health.
Beyond the staggering death toll, countless others endure debilitating illnesses, from heart disease to neurological impairments, stemming from the toxic cocktail we inhale daily. Illness is also more severe with overall increased hospitalizations.
The health effects of many toxic pollutants are often uncovered years after millions have been exposed. Think about the tobacco industry. The fossil fuel industry has picked up the same playbook, with executives prioritizing profits over people and bottom lines over lives. But unlike tobacco, none can escape the pervasive reach of polluted air, with 36% of Americans breathing unhealthy air, per EPA standards.
While everyone is impacted, some are more impacted than others, with children, pregnant women, disadvantaged communities, the elderly and those with other illnesses being disproportionately affected. Pregnant women living near power plants have the highest rates of stillbirth. Nationally, people of color are 61% more likely to live in a county with failing grades for air quality. Black residents are twice as likely to have asthma.
Despite all this, when my patient comes in with lung cancer that has metastasized to the brain, we don’t say this is from fossil fuel combustion, though we know exactly how particulate matter leads to lung adenocarcinoma and that about 20% of lung cancer cases are from fossil fuel pollution. When my patient who lives next to a diesel truck stop or an incinerator has a heart attack, we don’t usually cite fossil fuels as the cause. When children die from asthma, we don’t put the cause of death as pollution, even though my physician colleagues in the U.K. now do.
Decreasing air pollution has direct and immediate health co-benefits for communities that enact the changes. New Jerseyans would benefit directly from clean energy. Numerous studies show that health benefits, decreased mortality and decreased days of lost wages would substantially outweigh implementation costs. Often costs of a change are considered stand-alone expenses without the context of the millions of dollars saved in public health and lost workdays. The Clean Air Act resulted in a savings of $30 for every $1 spent. Public health measures — provisions that provide clean air, water, and soil — are cheaper than polluting, because people maintain their health.
The supposition that the market should dictate decisions ignores lives lost and illnesses caused by fossil fuel pollution. We must not assume that fossil fuel executives and their lobbyists have our best interests at heart. The rapid adoption of a Clean Energy Standard is part of an important public health agenda where the lives, health and well-being of all New Jerseyans are valued. This is why physicians care about energy.