Recent data from state and industry sources shows a sharp slowing in the number of building permits issued for warehouse construction last year in New Jersey. Those sources also show a new rise in vacancies, and a lower rate of increase in rents for the giant buildings, which have been springing up throughout the state for several years.

Analysts and companies that collect data on the industry say the breakneck pace of growth over the last several years can’t be sustained because supply from developers has already exceeded demand from customers. High interest rates are deterring investors from adding more space and uncertainty over economic growth is sapping confidence in any further expansion, they say.

The data on rents, vacancies and building permits suggest that warehouse tenants are less willing to pay top dollar for space; that more of the vast structures are remaining empty after a frenzy of speculative construction, and that developers are scaling back plans to build more of them.

Industry sources also note that developers continue to feel headwinds from warehouse opponents fighting the buildings at the local level. In the Legislature, two dozen warehouse-related bills first introduced last year now await consideration by lawmakers in response to rising local concern that the buildings are snarling traffic, worsening air quality, and contributing to warehouse “sprawl.”

According to data from New Jersey’s Department of Community Affairs, the area covered by building permits for “storage” buildings — mostly warehouses — in 2023 dropped sharply to 16.2 million square feet, a decline of about half compared with the previous two years, and the lowest level since 2018.

Monitoring vacancy rates and interest rates

Tim Brill, a land-use specialist at the New Jersey Conservation Foundation, said the DCA data appears to have been driven by high vacancy rates in existing warehouses, high interest rates and the reduced availability of commercial loans. In the first half of 2023, the number of building permits may also have been boosted by the state’s new stormwater regulations which spurred a surge of applications for projects that would be subject to less strict requirements before the regulations because effective in July, Brill said.

“This year, we’re seeing a rate that’s a little more than half of what it was in 2021 and 2022,” he said.

But Dan Kennedy, president of the New Jersey chapter of NAIOP, a trade group for the commercial real estate industry, argued that the DCA data is more likely to signal a return to a normal pattern of economic activity after the upward distortions prompted by the pandemic.

Even before the pandemic, the surge in construction was driven by consumers’ shift to online ordering, requiring logistics companies to find space to store a mountain of goods before delivery.

“DCA’s data reflects more of a return to normal rather than a negative outlook due to variables that normally drive the pace of construction, such as higher interest rates, environmental regulations, and zoning,” Kennedy said.

In the last five years, New Jersey added more than 43 million square feet of warehouse space, an increase of about 9% over the previous five years, according to Newmark, a commercial real estate firm that publishes quarterly reports on the market. And despite the recent signs of a slowdown, the industry still has 10.1 million square feet of warehousing in the pipeline, the company said in February.

Even before the pandemic, the surge in construction was driven by consumers’ shift to online ordering, requiring logistics companies to find space to store a mountain of goods before delivery. The trend was fueled by consumers who were forced to stay at home during the pandemic.

NJ, warehouse central

New Jersey’s growing reputation as the “warehouse state” is further boosted by its position at the heart of the populous Northeast; its dense network of highways and rail lines, and its status as an entry point for a flood of imported consumer goods through the Port of Newark/Elizabeth, one of the busiest container ports in the country.

First-quarter data from Newmark shows the vacancy rate for industrial real estate — mostly warehouses — in north and central New Jersey rose 1.4 percentage points from a year ago to 4.4%. The increase was the biggest since the first quarter of 2010. 

‘The market is recalibrating, with vacancy expected to rise in the remainder of 2024 as highly optimized construction deliveries continue to outpace net absorption.’ — Newmark report

Newmark called the increase “substantial” and attributed it to a slowdown in leasing activity and an increase in newly built space.

Net absorption, an industry term that measures the rate at which new buildings get occupied, turned negative for the first time since the first quarter of 2015, indicating that demand was not keeping up with supply.

“As new construction has delivered, there has been an oversupply of space while tenant demand has regressed since the highs reported during the peak of the COVID-19 pandemic,” a Newmark spokesman said. “These factors, combined with a slowdown in leasing activity and an uptick in available space, led to more space being added to the market than was removed.”

‘Tightening economic conditions’

And the amount of industrial space sought by tenants dropped 17% from a year earlier to 5.4 million square feet, driven by more frequent tenant consolidations and downsizing. Only six leases in north and central New Jersey were for 150,000 square feet or more during the first quarter, compared with 11 a year earlier, Newmark said.

The amount of new industrial space under construction dropped to 12.8 million square feet from 14 million in the prior quarter as developers and investors responded to “tightening economic conditions,” the report said.

Despite the rising vacancy rate, asking rents rose again to a record $16.83 a square foot.

“The market is recalibrating, with vacancy expected to rise in the remainder of 2024 as highly optimized construction deliveries continue to outpace net absorption,” the report said.

In response to the signs of slowing demand, many warehouse landlords looked for opportunities to divide their space in the first three months of this year because of “a large share of big-box space that has been vacant for an extended time” and a sharp increase in asking rents over the last four or five years, Newmark said.

But even with those shifts, northern and central New Jersey will remain a “globally important hub for investors and logistics activity,” the company said.

Rents still rose

Despite the rising vacancy rate, asking rents rose again to a record $16.83 a square foot, driven by demand for  top-class “optimized” space even though there was more space available in the overall market, the report said.

In South Jersey, the vacancy rate for industrial real estate rose to 8.5% in the latest quarter from 5.6% in 2020, Newmark said in a separate report for the Greater Philadelphia market. Asking rents in the market dropped by 2.1% from a year earlier, their first decline for seven years, as demand softened, the Newmark report said.

Many of the Philadelphia market’s largest leases during the latest period were in South Jersey, including a Burlington County development of 668,000 square feet, and another of 371,000 square feet in Salem County, the report said.

The Newmark data broadly matches research from Cushman & Wakefield, a global real estate firm, which found the vacancy rate for industrial buildings in central New Jersey rose to 6.5% in the first quarter, more than double the 2.9% in the first quarter of 2023. In northern New Jersey, the latest vacancy rate was at 6%, also more than twice the year-ago rate.

Nationally, the first-quarter vacancy rate rose to 5.8% from 3.5% a year ago and is expected to increase further in the coming 12 months amid a “marked” decline in construction starts, Cushman & Wakefield said.