
The team at NJ Spotlight News needs to be lauded for their efforts to launch “The Change Project” series. It’s easy to complain about the myriad economic, fiscal and social challenges facing New Jersey today, but it’s another to create a platform like this to allow for a robust policy debate and an exchange of ideas aimed at solving problems to bring about positive change.
The Garden State Initiative is grateful for the opportunity to positively contribute to this discourse and share our views in response to Budget and Finance writer John Reitmeyer’s thoughtful and detailed story about New Jersey’s flawed budget process.
For years, GSI has pointed out how a serious discussion about real solutions to New Jersey’s economic and fiscal challenges has been consistently muted by an abbreviated budget process that lacks meaningful public input. Not only has this lack of transparency in our state’s budget process made it difficult for important voices to be heard, but it also has increased the opaqueness of our state’s true financial condition from taxpayers.
As in John Reitmeyer’s report, we pointed to the Report of the State Budget Crisis Task Force by the Volcker Alliance, which identified New Jersey as one of only a handful of states sharply criticized for the consistent use of budget gimmicks, the absence of meaningful multiyear planning, and financial reporting that failed to fully articulate the future costs of financial obligations long since made.
Fiscal cliff
In an effort to help better inform state legislators, business owners and the general public, GSI recently published a new report titled “New Jersey’s Fiscal Cliff Explained” — going into painstaking detail about the economic and fiscal storm clouds that are gathering, as well as commonsense solutions we believe could make a difference.
Make no mistake, New Jersey’s fiscal reckoning is upon us and needs to be spoken about in plain words so that every taxpayer has a clear picture of what the future will portend for them.
That future, outlined in our report, shows that at current levels and trends of spending, New Jersey will need to collect at least $5 billion of incremental revenues by 2028 just to keep up. What does that mean for state taxpayers? For one, not a single taxpayer — no matter how low your family income or household spending needs — will be spared more pain.
For example, if the state were to generate that revenue solely through income taxes, those with annual incomes between $100,000 and $250,000 would pay an additional $1,650 annually; those between $250,001 and $500,000 would pay an additional $4,700; those between $500,001 and $1 million would pay an additional $11,500; and those with incomes over $1 million would pay a whopping $71,000 more. Even those earning between $35,000 and $50,000 would see their income tax bill approach $1,000 a year.
How about sales taxes? There, too, families will all face a massive increase. The state sales tax rate would need to rise from its current rate of 6.625% to nearly 9.1%. That would mean the sales tax on a new $35,000 car would go from $2,300 to nearly $3,200, while the purchase of a $500 major appliance would see a sales tax increase of more than 37%.
Other examples abound. To raise the $5 billion from our largest employers will mean doubling the corporate tax revenues from today’s $5 billion to $10 billion — and assuming no loss of jobs or companies operating here.
Behind closed doors
Most taxpayers have no idea this tax tsunami is on the horizon and ready to significantly raise the cost of living in New Jersey due to the way Trenton does business. Imagine running your own household or small business with this lack of visibility into the next few years? Sadly, that is exactly what this lack of understanding of the state budget process is doing to each one of us.
The reality is that our state budget is negotiated behind closed doors by a handful of people, dropped on the laps of state legislators who have largely been kept in the dark, with the expectation that they will vote on it without even having the opportunity to read the document.
For that reason, GSI encourages all readers and policymakers to embrace reforms outlined in NJ Spotlight’s John Reitmeyer’s piece. His ideas include the creation of multiyear budget assessments that project beyond the current budget into the future and regularly “stress-testing” budgets to better prepare for economic changes. Complementing this are other worthy reforms: requiring mid-year reviews with the purpose of making adjustments when goals are not being achieved; requiring annual spending to be completely and truly covered by annual recurring revenues; mandating the final state budget bill be made public seven days before a vote for final passage to allow for more scrutiny; and the addition of a detailed annual capital report that details the state’s capital assets and planned investments.
The time for this conversation is now and we’re eager to be a part of it before this year is a repeat of the last.