Credit: (AP Photo/Seth Wenig)
Editor’s note: The following article is published as part of a collaborative news project covering the 2023 legislative elections. Funded by the New Jersey Civic Information Consortium, the project includes New Jersey news organizations large and small and comprises articles on individual races and broader issues, as well as the NJ Voters Guide.
We asked politely several times in emails beginning in early August. We made phone calls. We reached out to candidates via social media. We urged, begged, pleaded and extended deadlines after they had come and gone. But more than 60% of candidates running for statewide office this year refused to participate in our NJ Voters Guide.
The lack of participation appears to be part of a growing trend among candidates to put fewer details into the public record, said Micah Rasmussen, director of the Rebovich Institute for New Jersey Politics at Rider University.
“Candidates are always looking for ways to control the messages they put out,” Rasmussen said. “They don’t want to be pinned down, and they don’t want to be put on the spot. None of that is new. What is changing, though, is they feel more emboldened; they feel like they can get away with opting out. They wouldn’t be doing it if there was a price to be paid for their non-participation.”
Rasmussen theorized that because we are in a politically polarized moment in which most voters fall into the partisan divide, there is less persuasion happening. “If fewer of us are open to being convinced, then there is less of a motivation to try and win over voters,” he said.
“The decline in local political coverage certainly plays a role as well — fewer of us are paying attention,” Rasmussen said. “I think all of these factors combine to give candidates permission to communicate in their preferred modes rather than ones that are imposed on them by the public, the media or public interest groups.”
Rasmussen noted that at all levels of government, more elected officials are keeping more information close to the vest.
“In my own local community, just as an example, our local officials prefer for members of the public to reach out to them on the phone,” he said. “While that’s a perfectly reasonable and personal way to communicate, it also happens to be a mode of communication in which different answers can be given to different people without accountability or comparison. That’s precisely why the gold standard for public communication will always be for everyone to have access to the same information at the same time.”
The questionnaire
The voter guide is funded by the New Jersey Civic Information Consortium, which was created by the state of New Jersey in 2018 in response to the decline in local news impacting communities in the state’s 21 counties.
We sent each candidate running for the New Jersey Senate and Assembly a brief email explaining the goal for the nonpartisan project — to provide voters with information that will allow them to make informed decisions. We told them answers would be edited for spelling and style but otherwise would run in full on the NJ Spotlight News’ website and in other publications across the state.
In the Assembly races, only 27% of Republican candidates participated, while 55% of Democratic Assembly candidates participated.
The questionnaire was meant to take less than 45 minutes to complete. We asked for a maximum of a paragraph answer for each question, and posed 10 questions to candidates, asking about their personal background, political background, why they are running for office, what a key issue is for them in this election and what solutions they are offering to address the issue. We asked candidates to list successful projects they have led and challenges they have overcome. Then we asked three policy questions: How, if at all, would you change New Jersey’s gun laws? Do you support the Murphy administration’s initiatives to combat climate change? How would you address the cost of rent, housing affordability and property taxes in New Jersey?
As of 11 p.m. on Oct. 25, just half of the Democratic candidates for Senate participated, while only 36% of Republican candidates for Senate participated. Only 1 of 8 independent candidates for Senate participated.
In the Assembly races, only 27% of Republican candidates participated, while 55% of Democratic Assembly candidates participated. Two of the 8 independent candidates seeking Senate seats participated.
Most Democratic candidates in party leadership positions did not participate, including Senate President Nicholas Scutari and Assembly Speaker Craig Coughlin. Anthony Bucco, the Republican Senate leader, did not respond to the questionnaire and neither did John DiMaio, the Republican leader in the Assembly.
About a dozen of the candidates participated after the other candidates’ forms were posted on NJ Spotlight News.
We emailed candidates asking why they had declined to participate and received no responses. In a few cases, representatives of candidates reached out to say they would participate in the next few days, but never did.
In more than one case, a candidate blocked our email address to stop receiving our requests for participation. More than three dozen candidates and leaders of state party organizations did not respond to any of our emails or participate, but immediately added our email addresses to their campaign email lists and began sending campaign e-blasts to us.
Republican candidate Robert Bedoya of Fort Lee called us when he was deliberating on whether to participate. He said a fellow Republican told him “it might be good for him.” He talked to the reporter for about an hour. The reporter explained that the answers are published verbatim, and that NJ Spotlight News and other participating organizations were nonpartisan news outlets. The reporter suggested a new daily nonpartisan media newsletter covering the State House that he might want to read. Bedoya then said there was only one trusted nonpartisan newsletter in the state he reads every day. He forwarded us the newsletter, which turned out to be the NJGOP Rapid Response newsletter. Near the end of the friendly chat, he said it was nice to talk to a Republican reporter. The reporter explained that she is an independent voter who is not affiliated with a political party. Bedoya seemed disappointed. He never filled out the candidate form.
Downward trend
The League of Women Voters of New Jersey, a nonpartisan organization, works to provide voters with information on candidates and public policy issues. Jesse Burns, the executive director of the organization, said the league has witnessed a downward trend in candidate participation in voter questionnaires over the past five years or so. The trend is more pronounced in less competitive districts.
“The less competitive a district is, the less compelled candidates feel the need to be accountable to voters,” Burns said.
The league routinely used to get more than 65% of candidates to participate in questionnaires. Participation is now down to about 30%, Burns said. The league asks questions based on priorities identified by voters.
“People call us all the time asking for information on candidates,” Burns said. “We want to give them a place to turn to. It’s getting harder and harder. We aren’t asking for that much time. We ask three to seven questions. Candidates aren’t taking the time to respond, so voters don’t have a place to get answers to policy issues. It’s very unfortunate.”
The league sends questions out in August, and constituents later reach out to candidates who have not participated yet, asking for responses so they know where the candidate stands on policy issues.
“We hear crickets. Silence,” Burns said. “It’s not really that respectful for a candidate to ignore these things.”
Holding candidates accountable
Candidates prioritize the questionnaires from organizations like labor unions that make decisions about endorsements based on candidates’ responses, Burns noted. They accuse the league of not being nonpartisan, but then don’t want to participate because the league is nonpartisan and doesn’t endorse candidates.
One Republican Party leader in Mercer County told the reporter that he advises candidates not to participate in League of Women Voters candidate forums or questionnaires. He claimed the league gives Democrats the questions beforehand so they can prepare. His evidence — candidates reading from prepared answers at league forums. When the reporter suggested that candidates anticipated questions and prepared a variety of answers for potential questions, he dismissed that as a possibility and insisted the Democrats were cheating with help from the league. As Burns noted, preparing for debates and forums by anticipating questions and preparing answers is a standard part of candidate preparation.
‘We need to start being more assertive at holding candidates accountable. It’s important for the future of our democracy.’ — Jesse Burns, League of Women Voters of New Jersey
“The accusation is upsetting and unfounded, and is an attack on the hundreds of volunteers who give their time to put candidate forums together,” Burns said. “Volunteers put these forums together and work to get candidates to answer questionnaires because they believe it is important to the future of democracy so voters have the best information to make choices at the ballot box.”
Burns said she doesn’t care about a candidate’s political affiliation.
“I care that we hold people in power accountable,” she said. “I also care that constituents are able to interact with their candidates and elected officials. We need to close the gap between the people sitting in Trenton and voters on the ground.
“Candidates think voters are not that smart. They are doing a disservice to New Jersey voters by not participating. What do they have to lose by responding? They need to take a risk instead of playing it safe. They need to respond, and owe it to the voters. We need to start being more assertive at holding candidates accountable. It’s important for the future of our democracy.”