This year’s legislative elections are shaping up to be the most costly in more than a decade. Candidates for all 120 seats in the New Jersey Senate and Assembly have spent some $19 million so far, according to the latest data from the state’s election watchdog.

The tab run up by independent political groups is almost half that — $9.4 million. And all of that $28.4 million is going to try and influence the results of what’s expected to be a low-turnout election.

Democrats are trying to hold decades-long majorities in both houses — a 25-15 margin in the Senate and 46-34 in the Assembly. But polling has shown issues around “parental rights” in schools and pushback against the Murphy administration’s climate change proposals are resonating among some voters, giving the GOP hope for at least narrowing those majorities.

So both parties have upped their fundraising efforts and are spending more than in any year since at least 2007. At this time in 2021, when the governor’s race topped balloting, legislative candidates had spent just $12.3 million.

As in recent elections, Democratic candidates are in a better financial position than Republicans. Democratic candidates have raised roughly three times what the GOP has — more than $27.8 million compared with $9.7 million. They also had spent more than twice as much as Republicans as of Oct. 10, the deadline for the first pre-general election reports released Wednesday by the Election Law Enforcement Commission, $13.8 million versus $5 million.

Rule changes

One explanation for the larger campaign accounts is the higher campaign contribution limits enacted as part of last April’s sweeping changes to campaign finance rules, according to Jeff Brindle, ELEC’s executive director. Candidates can now receive $5,200 per election from contributors, who can also give as much as $14,400 to campaign and political committees. Both of those increased limits are double what they were before Gov. Phil Murphy signed the law incorporating the changes. Contribution limits to party and other committees increased, as well.

“In addition, the political stakes are big. Republicans gained seats in the past two legislative elections and are looking to add more,” Brindle said. “At the same time, Democrats are fighting to maintain majorities they have held since 2002.”

While incumbents generally outraised and outspent challengers by at least 2-1, that was not necessarily the case in some of the state’s most hotly contested districts.

Two years ago, Republicans spent almost no money to upset then-Senate President Steve Sweeney and fellow Democratic Assembly members in South Jersey’s 3rd District.

Now an incumbent, Sen. Ed Durr (R-Gloucester) and his running mates have raised $283,000 and spent a little less than half that, according to ELEC reports. The Democratic challengers led by John Burzichelli, a former assemblyman ousted with Sweeney in 2021, have raised nearly five times more, $1.1 million, and spent double, $380,000. The Democrats had about five times more cash on hand going into the last month of the campaign, as well.

While money didn’t matter two years ago in the Republican sweep of the district, it could this year, as the Democrats are attacking Durr directly, something they did not do in 2021. Independent spending has so far been low in this race, $82,573, the reports show.

Topping the list

With just $600,000 spent in total through Oct. 10, the 3rd District race ranks as the seventh most expensive of eight districts expected to be competitive.

Leading all is Monmouth County’s 11th District, where representation is already split between Democratic Sen. Vin Gopal and Republican Assembly members Kim Eulner and Marilyn Piperno. Democrats lost the Assembly seats in 2021 while Gopal was able to hold the Senate seat.

The five biggest spenders thus far among the independent committees are all working to elect Democrats, particularly in competitive districts.

Both parties would like to take control of all three legislative spots. Through Oct. 10, the candidates and independent spending committees had spent $5.6 million and ELEC expects, when all is said and done, that this race will wind up being one of the 10 most expensive in state history.

Here again, Democrats have a huge money advantage, with the $3.5 million spent by Gopal and his team — about eight times more than Stephen Dnistrian and the incumbent GOP Assembly members.

The same pattern repeats in Central Jersey’s 16th District and the 4th in South Jersey, where Democrats currently hold all the seats and constitute a plurality among registered voters. Political observers nonetheless expect close races.

Independent groups

Not only are Democratic candidates raising more money than Republicans, but they are also benefiting more from the independent spending reported so far. Just 14 groups have spent almost $9.4 million to influence New Jersey races this year, compared with $2.3 million by this point in 2021, according to ELEC.

The five biggest spenders thus far among the independent committees are all working to elect Democrats, particularly in competitive districts.

The top spender was Middle Ground, an independent committee formed earlier this year. The group got $900,000 from Garden State Forward, the political committee of the state’s largest teachers union, and spent money to support Democrats in the 11th and 16th districts, as well as the 38th in Bergen County. Democrats have held those seats for the last two decades but some continue to see the race as possibly competitive.

The NJEA’s Garden State Forward and three other groups — Prosperity Rising NJ Inc., Stronger Foundations Inc. and Growing Economic Opportunities — spent more than $1 million apiece in support of Democrats in the state.

The top independent spender backing GOP candidates was the Republican State Leadership Committee, which ranked as the sixth biggest spender statewide, having laid out $405,000 through the end of September.

Over the summer, the committee announced its support for candidates in nine districts, some of which the party now controls and others where it is seeking to flip seats. These include the 3rd, 4th, 11th and 16th, considered to be among the most competitive in the state.

ELEC’s report includes information reported by candidates as of Monday and committees as of Tuesday. Candidates and committees must file one more pre-election report, 11 days prior to the Nov. 7 election.