Op-Ed: NJ schools need a real system of accountability to ensure equity for students

The State Board of Education is in the process of adopting a code, but it’s not enough

Peter T. Rosario | May 3, 2023 | Education, Opinion

Peter T. Rosario

New Jersey’s State Board of Education defines educational equity as “a set of policies, programs, and practices that emphasizes high expectations and achievement patterns, and ensures equitable access to educational opportunity for all learners, including students and teachers.” 

This definition is part of New Jersey Administrative 6A:7, “Managing for Equality and Equity in Education,” which the board is now in the process of adopting. This code is filled with lots of evidence-based language and best practices. In many ways, it reads as a best-in-class model. 

However, in reality, this code is just a checklist exercise for school districts to complete with next-to-zero accountability to students and their parents. 

Here are just four real-life examples of how inequity impacts our parents and students, every day: 

  • In one high school, foreign-born immigrant students ask the native-born Black and Puerto Ricans students to accompany them to meet with an administrator, so they get excused to participate in clubs and athletics. If they go alone this administrator will deny them “hall passes,” but if they go with an “American” kid he can’t deny them access. 
  • In another high school, a child returns to school after being saved by paramedics with Narcan from overdosing on opioids. This child did not meet with a substance abuse counselor until six weeks later when they were caught “using” again in a locker room. 
  • In an elementary school, a child returns to school after being in a treatment center for violence and anger management. The district assigns the child a one-on-one paraprofessional, who has not received proper restraint training. When the parents ask if the paraprofessional will receive the training, the response was “We only have a couple of people trained in the whole school.” 
  • In another school district, 90% of the eligible children of color participate in free and reduced-cost lunch programs. However, only 33% of eligible white children participate in free and reduced-cost lunch programs. 

You may say to yourself, wait, why is this last one a problem? Isn’t it great that we are serving more children of color than white children? Well, the reality is that for this school district, for every child of color that was eligible for the lunch programs, there were five white children that were also eligible to participate in the program. This means hundreds of white children were not receiving a benefit they are entitled to receive. In one school, white parents were discouraged from applying, because they were told, “We don’t want people to think the neighborhood is changing.”  

Yup, let that one sink in. Allow me to rephrase it for you. “Our neighborhood’s image is more important than helping to ensure your child is properly fed.” 

What equity should look like

Each of these scenarios is different, but they all should point us to a much simpler definition of what equity should look like in our state. 

Simply put, managing for equity ensures that we value children as individuals and that we provide them with every possible opportunity and resource to learn, grow and thrive. 

One would think that an administrative code titled “Managing for Equality and Equity in Education” would ensure that the scenarios I listed above are reported, investigated and resolved in a timely manner. 

But that’s not the case. The essence of this code revolves around the submission of a three-year “Comprehensive Equity Plan,” which is essentially a checklist of exercises and statements of assurance that are prepared by local school districts and submitted to the county Department of Education office. 

Does anyone read them or care? Take a moment and open a new tab on your browser and type in “Comprehensive Equity Plan (insert your town’s name), N.J.” 

First, if you are lucky, the document you open will actually be up to date and reflect a current three-year cycle. For many of us, that will not be the case. 

Second, read through what is actually in your district’s plan. I can assure you that you will read a whole bunch of “Yes” answers with a smattering of “No” answers. Each “No” will be accompanied by “corrective” steps or action plans. 

In too many cases, you will not find any reporting on the number of incidents related to inequality or inequity that occurred in your local district. The same goes for a clearly defined process for parents or students to report incidents of inequity or inequality. 

How can we ensure that local school boards and administrators take equality and equity seriously? What does accountability look like? 

We don’t need to look much further than New Jersey’s anti-bullying laws that were enacted in response to the suicide of Tyler Clementi in 2010. 

While no law is perfect, the harassment, intimidation and bullying laws, or HIB laws, policies and regulations articulate a clearly defined reporting and accountability system that ensures local administrators and school board members take every incident of harassment, intimidation and bullying seriously. 

Ultimately, a similar reporting and accountability system must be developed to ensure local school districts take equality and equity seriously. Here are the essential components that must be included in an accountability system to ensure equity in education for all students. 

  • Every school must have an equity specialist responsible for reporting, investigating and resolving issues related to equity and equality. 
  • Every school district must have a director assigned to supervise specialists. 
  • The names of the director and specialists should be published on websites, social media and other school publications. 
  • All incidents must be reported to the local school board on a monthly basis. 
  • All school districts should report data at regular public meetings. 
  • All school districts should hold public hearings twice a year to review data and reports and seek public input on this information. 

To paraphrase the Scottish poet Robert Burns’ observation over 200 years ago, “the best laid plans of mice and men often go awry.” Readoption of 6A:7 without a true reporting and accountability system will continue to lead our children and families awry.