Credit: (Wikimedia Commons/CC BY-SA 4.0)If there is any positive outcome from the COVID-19 pandemic, it is that youth mental health services moved to the forefront in 2022. But as the year also showed, the hard part may be in deciding what happens next in maintaining those services.
Youth mental health was a top priority for school personnel, families, students and lawmakers in 2022 like never before, as young people across the state continued to navigate the emotional tolls amplified by the pandemic.
Gov. Phil Murphy’s $50.6 billion state budget, the largest in the state’s history, allocated over $50 million in American Rescue Plan funding to strengthen youth mental health supports. The budget seeks to increase the number of behavioral health care workers going into the profession.
But indicative of the debates ahead, one of the biggest policy fights of the year was over a proposal from the Murphy administration to revamp mental health services in schools.
Announced in late September by the state Department of Children and Families, the plan called for the end of the current school-based youth services available in 90 schools throughout the state and in place since the late 1980s. Instead, it would replace them with a new regional “hub and spoke” model titled the New Jersey Statewide Student Support Services network (NJ4S) by June 30, 2023.
This new approach, state officials said, would provide mental health resources to more students across the state to address the youth mental health crisis exacerbated by the pandemic.
But significant pushback came from educators, advocates and state legislators on both sides of the aisle, who contended the replacement plan would gut a successful model. After weeks of debate, Murphy pulled back and announced that the current school-based youth services programs would remain and be funded for another school year while the regional network was being developed.
Now, advocates and school personnel are looking ahead with concern over what’s next and how youth mental health needs will be addressed in the coming years.
Worries over the new model
“The hub and spoke system [of the regional plan] from what I have seen … I’m not convinced that this is actually the way to go,” said Julie Larrea Borst, the executive director of Save Our Schools New Jersey Community Organizing, an advocacy group that took up the cause for the in-school programs.
Borst added that she wished the state was more focused on expanding the current school-based youth services programs. “We know that they work,” she said.
“Nationally, you can look to community schools and the delivery of services in schools because it’s meeting kids where they are,” Borst said. “Is that perfect for everybody? No, of course not. Should there be services available outside of school? Yes, absolutely. … But I feel like that should be more and more of a supporting kind of a role.”
School-based programs do draw considerable support nationally, too. In the 2021-2022 school year, 96% of public schools reported offering at least one type of mental health service to their students, according to the Kaiser Family Foundation.
‘The real hope was that the governor was going to realize how critical these programs are to communities of color in particular — that that would be thought of and examined, but it wasn’t.’ — Gary Nelson, Making Visions Possible
School-based mental health services can improve access to care, allow for early identification and treatment of mental health issues and may be linked to reduced absenteeism and better mental health outcomes, according to the foundation. The services can also reduce access barriers for underserved populations, including children from low-income households and children of color, the foundation noted.
The best way forward is to keep the current school-based programs and empower those programs to be able to serve more than just the host school they are located in, said Gary Nelson, the program director of Making Visions Possible, a school-based youth services program at Willingboro High School.
“Ideally, we would have received a stronger commitment from the governor other than agreeing to extend it for one year,” said Nelson. “The real hope was that the governor was going to realize how critical these programs are to communities of color in particular — that that would be thought of and examined, but it wasn’t,” he added.
In Middlesex County, other school districts have in place in-school services and also might not need the regional program, added Kristina Nicosia, the superintendent for the Highland Park public school district. But she acknowledged some school districts might benefit from it.
“So how about taking a look at what all districts in New Jersey are doing in terms of mental health services,” Nicosia suggested. “Where are the gaps? And then … if they have funding available, what can be used either with this ‘hub and spoke’ model or some other process to fill in the gaps as needed. And I think that’s the area that was missed.”
Nicosia said she was happy to see the governor reach a compromise that included both models while the regional approach is tested.
“Can it really actually mirror what is happening in the schools with these robust, effective programs now?” Nicosia said. “Because if you can promise me that what they’re going to offer me is the same, if not better than what I’m getting now, I’m all in, 1,000% for it. But until I see that, I’m not entirely convinced.”



